Andy Reid with 2nd Most Playoff Wins in NFL History

[FloridaMan88]

Originally Posted by Wallcrawler

Shocking development: Beat qb in the universe falls into notorious multi franchise playoff choker's lap and his post season fortunes drastically improve.

Shocking development: You are a Reerunned fraud.

You don’t have a problem with the fact that Lombardi won zero postseason games without Bart Starr.

You don’t have a problem with the fact that Bill Walsh was 6-19 with zero postseason APPEARANCES without Montana/Young as his QB.

Yet you hold Andy to a different standard.

Explain.

[tredadda]

Originally Posted by KCChiefsFan88

Shocking development: You are a Reerunned fraud.

You don’t have a problem with the fact that Lombardi won zero postseason games without Bart Starr.

You don’t have a problem with the fact that Bill Walsh was 6-19 with zero postseason APPEARANCES without Montana/Young as his QB.

Yet you hold Andy to a different standard.

Explain.

What’s wild is that Andy has as many or more playoff wins WITHOUT a HOF QB than these HCs have in their career (HOF QB or not):

Dan Reeves (who had Elway)
Bill Parcells
Marc Levy (who had Kelly)
Bud Grant (who had Tarkenton)
Siefert (who had Young)
Walsh (who had Montana)
Payton (who had Brees)
Dungy (who had Manning)
Madden
Lombardi (who had Starr)

That’s just a few as I stopped listing. Point being that Andy is one of the greatest HCs of all time. He needed Mahomes to get him over the top (as is the case with almost all SB winning HCs), he did more with less than almost every HC in the history of the NFL.

[Bl00dyBizkitz]

Originally Posted by tredadda

What’s wild is that Andy has as many or more playoff wins WITHOUT a HOF QB than these HCs have in their career (HOF QB or not):

Dan Reeves (who had Elway)
Bill Parcells
Marc Levy (who had Kelly)
Bud Grant (who had Tarkenton)
Siefert (who had Young)
Walsh (who had Montana)
Payton (who had Brees)
Dungy (who had Manning)
Madden
Lombardi (who had Starr)

That’s just a few as I stopped listing. Point being that Andy is one of the greatest HCs of all time. He needed Mahomes to get him over the top (as is the case with almost all SB winning HCs), he did more with less than almost every HC in the history of the NFL.

But the playoff chokes!!!
The losses where he was expected to win!!!
Anybody could win a Super Bowl with Mahomes!!!!

[FloridaMan88]

WallFaller finds it more impressive to not make the postseason at all without a HOF-caliber QB, than to make the playoffs with a lesser QB and supposedly “choke” (his description).

Because his beloved Lombardi/Bill Walsh had a combined ZERO postseason appearances without a HOF-caliber QB.

That impresses WallFaller.