The 49ers were wrong about Alex Smith

[Mr. Flopnuts]

http://bleacherreport.com/articles/2...gn=programming

The 49ers Got It Wrong on Alex Smith, and He's Proving It with the Chiefs
By Mike Freeman , NFL National Lead Writer Oct 3, 2014


Offensive guard Geoff Schwartz remembers the first time he saw Kansas City Chiefs quarterback Alex Smith run in a game. Smith escaped from the pocket, and what Schwartz saw shocked him.

"Whoa, I didn't think he was that fast," Schwartz said to himself.

Schwartz is now with the Giants but played with Smith in Kansas City in 2013. Schwartz isn't the only guy to be unexpectedly amazed by Smith. When Smith was in San Francisco and was shockingly permanently benched for Colin Kaepernick after suffering a concussion—the team was 6-2, and Smith was having his best statistical season—one 49ers player remembered what the locker room was like after the controversial move.

There were two camps developing: one for Kaepernick and the other for Smith.

While the player explained it would be hyperbole to say a civil war was emerging, he said, "The locker room was headed to a potentially bad place. Then Alex changed things."


Smith told teammates opposed to his benching, in no uncertain terms, to back Kaepernick. The player remembers Smith's actions as the most selfless thing he's seen in his NFL career.

Kaepernick told reporters this week, speaking of Smith and his benching:

I think he definitely made things go a lot smoother. I mean, the way he handled things didn't turn it into a controversy in the locker room. It shows the character that he has, not only as a player but as a man.

(He's) one of the classiest people I've been around—just all-around great guy. I don't think anyone could've handled it as well as he did.

I'm told that Kaepernick at the time basically said to Smith that he would never forget how Smith handled the situation.

"Did he want to be on the field? Yes," Kaepernick said. "But he wasn't going to let that get in the way of what the team was trying to do."

Said Smith to the media this week: "I actively tried to be a good teammate and tried to do what was right. This is a team game, and I wasn't going to put myself or my situation ahead of any of that. I know I said this at the time, and I still feel the same way: No one is bigger than the team."

This is who Alex Smith is. Probably how he's always been. And there's so much more.

In many ways, it is Smith's unselfishness that makes him great. It is also that unselfishness that makes him vastly underappreciated.

Smith has been called a game-manager, which in the past was the NFL equivalent of a slur. A game-managing quarterback is basically told to just stay the hell out of the way while the real men do the job.


What many of us—including me—missed about Smith in the past was just how explosive his skill set can be. That potential was buried in conservative 49ers systems that didn't always trust him (but should have).

As Smith heads back to San Francisco on Sunday, versus the team that dumped him for Kaepernick, what we've learned is this: Game-manager is no longer an insult when it comes to Smith. In many ways, he has changed the definition of the term.

Smith isn't the guy he was with the 49ers. He has grown into more than just efficient. He's become dangerous, a quarterback who can make every throw on the field. Game-manager? Game-destroyer. He's gone from tepid to explosive, and the transformation of two franchises became complete.

"Every QB is a 'game-manager,'" Schwartz said. "Russell Wilson is a game-manager just like Alex Smith. He does what's asked of him."

Schwartz wasn't criticizing Wilson. He was stating a fact. Wilson and Smith have talent, but they also don't make a ton of mistakes. Smith can do anything. If the Chiefs need him to throw for 180 yards and run for 40, he can. If they need him to do what he did against the Patriots, throwing for 248 yards and three scores with a passer rating of 144.4, he can do that too.

Alex Smith's Career Stats
Year Team W-L Cmp% Y/G TD INT Rating
2005 49ers 2-5 50.9% 97.2 1 11 40.8
2006 49ers 7-9 58.1% 180.6 16 16 74.8
2007 49ers 2-5 48.7% 130.6 2 4 57.2
2009 49ers 5-5 60.5% 213.6 18 12 81.5
2010 49ers 3-7 59.6% 215.5 14 10 82.1
2011 49ers 13-3 61.3% 196.5 17 5 90.7
2012 49ers 6-2-1 70.2% 173.7 13 5 104.1
2013 Chiefs 11-4 60.6% 220.9 23 7 89.1
2014 Chiefs 2-2 65.6% 222.8 7 3 94.2
Pro-Football-Reference.com

"Some QBs are asked to do more," Schwartz said.

"Just look at our playoff game," Schwartz added, referring to a 45-44 Wild Card loss to the Colts, in which Jamaal Charles left after the first play with a concussion. "Losing Jamaal, we needed more from Alex."

And what did Smith give them? He had 378 yards and four passing touchdowns. He was asked to change his game and carry the offense, and he was incredible.

The alleged game-manager morphed into Dan Fouts.

What we're seeing with Smith is maybe a guy who all along could do many things on the football field but was asked to do only a few. Maybe everyone except Chiefs head coach Andy Reid saw that.

When Smith came out of Utah in 2005, the Eagles—then coached by Reid—had a very high grade on him. Reid always loved Smith and wanted to coach him, I'm told. So when the opportunity arose, he jumped at it.


Reid gave Smith advice this week on the best way to approach returning to play an old team. He did this himself recently when the Chiefs played in Philadelphia. Reid explained to reporters:

You focus in on what you do. All the distractions, going home and all that—it doesn’t mean anything. You’re there to play the game and once you’ve said hi to your buddies it’s over. You’re playing the game, that’s what you’re doing. You’ve got to prepare and you’ve got to go through all the steps here on Wednesday, Thursday, Friday, Saturday. That’s what it is, everything else is kind of fluff. Everybody talks about it but that’s not what’s real. The real is you get in the grind and get yourself ready to play a game.

Smith has always meant many things to many people. To the 49ers, he was a passer of a torch. To Kaepernick, he took a seldom-used high road. To the Chiefs, he is everything. He is malleable.

What Smith is, most of all, is good. In every way.

Just plain good.



Mike Freeman covers the NFL for Bleacher Report.

[htismaqe]

Originally Posted by Direckshun

I think it's just fascinating the argument is even being had.

For sure.

[Easy 6]

Originally Posted by Direckshun

Yeah, Jason Kidd's like one of the best passers in NBA history.

Your analogy is invalid. I have decreed it so.

Whatever lol, you might have me on the passing but its still valid.

Smith is one of the greats at not committing turnovers, so I guess they both have one true strength.

[Baby Lee]

Originally Posted by Direckshun

I'll say this, the article, which is largely stuff we already knew about the guy, does contain one great nugget:

That Alex Smith and Russell Wilson have changed the NFL's perspective of what a really good game manager's value can be.

I agree that, since these two of taken off over the past three years, that the term is less and less of a slur. Nowadays, it's a different perspective on the QB position.

Nice to see the world turn to my view. I was saying clear back in the early aughts, that a great game manager gets you a Troy Aikman, or Joe Montana for that matter.

[dls6501]

Originally Posted by Easy 6

Smith is a complete NFL quarterback... he's like the Jason Kidd of football, not truly spectacular at any one thing, but rock solid in every aspect.

This is the dumbest comparison I have ever heard. Kidd was a 10x all star and a 5x first team All-NBA.

[htismaqe]

Originally Posted by Baby Lee

Nice to see the world turn to my view. I was saying clear back in the early aughts, that a great game manager gets you a Troy Aikman, or Joe Montana for that matter.

Get back to me when Alex Smith is surrounded by All-Pro talent at nearly every position, offense AND defense...

That's what one needs to win a championship with a "game manager".

[Easy 6]

Originally Posted by dls6501

This is the dumbest comparison I have ever heard. Kidd was a 10x all star and a 5x first team All-NBA.

Get on your knees, noob.

Kidd didnt truly excel at any one aspect other than assists.

[Hammock Parties]

Originally Posted by Easy 6

Get on your knees, noob.

Kidd didnt truly excel at any one aspect other than assists.

He was also an above average 3-point shooter and always a great defender.

Don't even start with this. I watched his entire career with Dallas.

[dls6501]

Originally Posted by Easy 6

Get on your knees, noob.

Kidd didnt truly excel at any one aspect other than assists.

So because I am new here, it makes the fact that I think that comparing Alex Smith to an all time great NBA player is reeruned, invalid?

And LOL at didnt excel in any one aspect other than assists. I guess being a 9x All Defensive player is meaningless too.

Comparing Alex to Jason Kidd is mind boggling. Absolutely idiotic.

[OldSchool]

Originally Posted by htismaqe

Get back to me when Alex Smith is surrounded by All-Pro talent at nearly every position, offense AND defense...

That's what one needs to win a championship with a "game manager".

He put up 43 points without a single "All-Pro" caliber player around him. I think we're fine with Smith.

He just needs a defense that can hold a 3+ score lead over less than 2 quarters of play.

[Mr. Flopnuts]

Originally Posted by Claynus

To act like this is decided is silly.

I totally agree with this. My opinion is not fact. Yet...

[Hammock Parties]

Originally Posted by OldSchool

He put up 43 points without a single "All-Pro" caliber player around him. I think we're fine with Smith.

He just needs a defense that can hold a 3+ score lead over less than 2 quarters of play.

Call me when he wins an important close game for this team. Especially when the opposition's offense is scoring 24+.

Blowouts rarely happen in the NFL.

[temper11]

Originally Posted by Direckshun

I'll say this, the article, which is largely stuff we already knew about the guy, does contain one great nugget:

That Alex Smith and Russell Wilson have changed the NFL's perspective of what a really good game manager's value can be.

I agree that, since these two of taken off over the past three years, that the term is less and less of a slur. Nowadays, it's a different perspective on the QB position.

this

[Mr. Flopnuts]

Originally Posted by Direckshun

I think it's just fascinating the argument is even being had.

Pretty much my thoughts and why I posted it.

[BIG_DADDY]

Kaepernick > Smith + getting the Chiefs to WAY overpay = Winning!!!!!

[Kaepernick]

Solid article. I reposted it on the 49ers forum.

Maybe I was wrong about Alex and he hadn't hit his ceiling in 2012. Maybe Alex is on his way to becoming a solid top 10 QB. I don't believe that yet and 4 games this year is too small of a sample set. Lets see what he does over 16 games in his 2nd year in Andy's system.

I did state in pre-season that Alex takes a couple of years to master a system, so you could not judge him only on 2011, and I went so far to predict thst he would be much improved in his 2nd year with the Chiefs.

I have always pegged him for a middle tier game manager at best, who would never achieve top 10 status because he was risk averse and lacked killer instinct.

I will be happy to eat crow if Andy has drawn out the killer instinct in Alex and inspires Him to take the appropriate risk at the critical time for the appropriate reward, instead of playing it safe.

You can't have too much top quarterback play in the NFL. Here is hoping Alex becomes a solid top 10 starting NFL quarterback. I won't choke on that crow.