Would you trade Alex Smith for Colin Kaepernick straight up?

[splatbass]

Originally Posted by Douche Baggins

Kaepernick has already won more playoff games in two years than Alex has in 8.

Kaepernik is a one-dimensional QB. He can't read defenses, and while he has a gun for an arm he is not particularly accurate and has no touch. He needs his running ability to set up his passing. If you take away his running ability and make him be a pocket passer (either by game plan or injury) he is a less than average QB.

Alex Smith is a good pocket QB that also has decent running ability when necessary.