Your OROTY is...

[Hootie]

Originally Posted by GoWalrus

Luck won. And he won more than these other two QBs. That's what matters.

How well do the Skins or Seahawks do if their gold-toof dawgs have to throw 650 times?

wtf are you even talking about? You're an idiot.

Russell Wilson is one of the best interviews in the NFL. The dude is as intelligent as they come.

AND if you watched the Falcons game...Wilson is every bit the passer Luck is at this stage of his career, and better.

He passed less because he played on an offense that utilized his strengths. Bruce Arians is stubborn. He was on NFL Network yesterday and his arrogance was fascinating. He is going to fail at Arizona and fail hard.

Luck can run the read option and should run the read option especially since you say they had no running game. That would have solved that issue and maybe they would have fared better in the postseason.

Your ability to judge QB's doesn't exist. I'd rebump our conversation about Eli before he won his Super Bowl(s) to show how ignorant you are when you talk about QB's but it is locked.

I'm not even bashing Luck. He had a very promising rookie year.

He was not as good as Russell Wilson. Not by any standard.

[spades]

Originally Posted by Peyton's Princess

wtf are you even talking about? You're an idiot.

Russell Wilson is one of the best interviews in the NFL. The dude is as intelligent as they come.

AND if you watched the Falcons game...Wilson is every bit the passer Luck is at this stage of his career, and better.

He passed less because he played on an offense that utilized his strengths. Bruce Arians is stubborn. He was on NFL Network yesterday and his arrogance was fascinating. He is going to fail at Arizona and fail hard.

Luck can run the read option and should run the read option especially since you say they had no running game. That would have solved that issue and maybe they would have fared better in the postseason.

Your ability to judge QB's doesn't exist. I'd rebump our conversation about Eli before he won his Super Bowl(s) to show how ignorant you are when you talk about QB's but it is locked.

I'm not even bashing Luck. He had a very promising rookie year.

He was not as good as Russell Wilson. Not by any standard.

This is the most reeruned thing I have read in quite some time. My god man.

[Hootie]

Originally Posted by spades

This is the most reeruned thing I have read in quite some time. My god man.

?

You're telling me Andrew Luck couldn't successfully run read option plays within their offense?

I am not suggesting he should be a read option QB, I'm saying Bruce Arians could have implemented the read option with his ATHLETIC QB that would have taken some pressure off of him to throw 50 times per game because they couldn't run the ball.

[spades]

Originally Posted by Peyton's Princess

?

You're telling me Andrew Luck couldn't successfully run read option plays within their offense?

I am not suggesting he should be a read option QB, I'm saying Bruce Arians could have implemented the read option with his ATHLETIC QB that would have taken some pressure off of him to throw 50 times per game because they couldn't run the ball.

You don't take a guy like luck and have him run the read option. Where Arians screwed up is by having hardly any checkdowns available. Very few screens and such. When he did call the rare TE screen, it worked very well.

Arians wanted to chuck it downfield every play even though the offensive line was horrible and nobody cared about playaction.

You say you love good qb play but call Luck mediocre this year? That is reeruned. You point to his completion percentage and say he was mediocre. What you don't look at is the other qb's in Arians system. It does not do the qb's any favors historically. How many times did RG3 throw screen passes? You put him or Wilson in Arians scheme and their production falls a good amount.

Also do you know how many drops the Colts had this year? I believe Avery and Hilton were 2 of the worst in the league. You can check that but you don't need to. It is accurate.

Packers, Lions, and Dolphins. Go watch Luck in those games and tell me he didn't pass the eyeball test as much as Wilson.

I am arguing for Luck. Not against Wilson. I really like that kid