Would you rather be 8-0 with Alex Smith or 3-5 with Geno?

[Halfcan]

Originally Posted by Bowser

See, I was greedy when it came to my view of Geno. If it were up to me, Geno would be here backing up Alex, so I can't answer the question as posed.

In my dream scenario, Geno would have been probably third string behind Alex and Chase, moves to backup next year, and been starting in 2015. Give him time that way to assimilate an NFL offense and how to prepare, conduct yourself (although he's had no problems with that in New York, a credit to him), and really get a feel for what it means to play QB in the league from Andy and Alex.

So Geno with the number 1 is better than Bray- for free?

[Bowser]

Originally Posted by Halfcan

So Geno with the number 1 is better than Bray- for free?

No way to know that, and we probably won't know that for a number of years.

Perhaps Bray will play that role I had envisioned Geno in. I certainly hope so. If it happens, well, that will be proof positive as to why I'm some anonymous idiot posting on message boards and John Dorsey is who he is.

[SAUTO]

Originally Posted by Halfcan

So Geno with the number 1 is better than Bray- for free?

We could have had them both...
Posted via Mobile Device