The Dark Knight Rises *Spoilers* Thread

[shorman22]

Is it just me or do you also believe that Nolan would come back and make another one. If he wanted to end it he could have ended inception like with the butler's smile.

[Deberg_1990]

Originally Posted by shorman22

Is it just me or do you also believe that Nolan would come back and make another one. If he wanted to end it he could have ended inception like with the butler's smile.

I dont see it. I think hes done.

Hes the most "real artist" of any of the comic book directors besides maybe Singer, and is probably ready to move on to something else and let someone elses vision take over.

[007]

Originally Posted by Deberg_1990

I dont see it. I think hes done.

Hes the most "real artist" of any of the comic book directors besides maybe Singer, and is probably ready to move on to something else and let someone elses vision take over.

Too bad Singer didn't do X3

[WhiteWhale]

Originally Posted by Deberg_1990

I dont see it. I think hes done.

Hes the most "real artist" of any of the comic book directors besides maybe Singer, and is probably ready to move on to something else and let someone elses vision take over.

Singer has directed 3 comic book movies. One was decent (X-2) one was bad (X-men) and one was just god awful (super-stalker-deadbeat-dad-man returns). He turned one of my favorite comics into 2 hour allegories for his own homosexuality. Vanity projects. I hate that he ever worked on them.

Nolan made 3 movies and all of them were anywhere from very good to excellent.

Even Raimi did good on two of three.

[JD10367]

Originally Posted by WhiteWhale

Singer has directed 3 comic book movies. One was decent (X-2) one was bad (X-men) and one was just god awful (super-stalker-deadbeat-dad-man returns). He turned one of my favorite comics into 2 hour allegories for his own homosexuality. Vanity projects. I hate that he ever worked on them.

Nolan made 3 movies and all of them were anywhere from very good to excellent.

Even Raimi did good on two of three.

I'd disagree with the "one was bad". I enjoyed the first "X-Men". And I actually thought "Superman Returns" wasn't as bad as everyone else does. Sure, it was a bit emo-homo, and the whole Superbaby thing was a little out there and didn't need to be done, but it had good visual style, and Brandon Routh did as good of a Christopher Reeve impersonation as he could. The problem with that film (other than the aforementioned Superbaby plot) was that they simply tried to continue the Reeve portrayal; this new version, taking Supes in a hopefully-darker direction, is at least a new interpretation of the character.