Vick to KC?

[stonedstooge]

Going to have to have some experienced quarterback. Would you rather they keep Casshole or Quinn?

[Oh Snap]

Originally Posted by stonedstooge

Going to have to have some experienced quarterback. Would you rather they keep Casshole or Quinn?

Jesus Christ! This all day errr day over Cassle and Quinn. Face it, Vick is head and shoulders above either one of those guys. The only issue I see with Vick is his durability. This past season Vick just couldn't stay healthy, and that cost the Eagles big time..

Some would call that a liability (to bring him in here)...But lets be honest. Compared to the current retreads we already have on roster, I think its well worth the risk. I personally don't want to see Cassel ever again on this team. HOWEVER, if he had to stay on the team, I wouldn't mind seeing him as a third string back up. Restructure Cassels contract and relegate him to third string. Thats about on par for his talent level imo.

1. Get Vick on the cheap for a couple years.
2. Draft Geno Smith.
3. ???????
4. Geno Smith learns the West Coast offense behind Vick for a year or two.
5. Profit.

I don't see any problem with that scenario.

[MahiMike]

Originally Posted by Oh Snap

Jesus Christ! This all day errr day over Cassle and Quinn. Face it, Vick is head and shoulders above either one of those guys. The only issue I see with Vick is his durability. This past season Vick just couldn't stay healthy, and that cost the Eagles big time..

Some would call that a liability (to bring him in here)...But lets be honest. Compared to the current retreads we already have on roster, I think its well worth the risk. I personally don't want to see Cassel ever again on this team. HOWEVER, if he had to stay on the team, I wouldn't mind seeing him as a third string back up. Restructure Cassels contract and relegate him to third string. Thats about on par for his talent level imo.

1. Get Vick on the cheap for a couple years.
2. Draft Geno Smith.
3. ???????
4. Geno Smith learns the West Coast offense behind Vick for a year or two.
5. Profit.

I don't see any problem with that scenario.

This. I said the same with Alex Smith. Get both. Train the kid.

[Oh Snap]

Originally Posted by MahiMike

This. I said the same with Alex Smith. Get both. Train the kid.

I don't have an issue with Alex Smith like a lot of people seem to have here. He has been in this league for several years now, and has invaluable NFL experience at QB. We won't win the Superbowl with Alex at the helm, but again, it comes down to transition. Draft Geno and let him sit for a year or two behind a proven NFL starter.

[MahiMike]

Originally Posted by Oh Snap

I don't have an issue with Alex Smith like a lot of people seem to have here. He has been in this league for several years now, and has invaluable NFL experience at QB. We won't win the Superbowl with Alex at the helm, but again, it comes down to transition. Draft Geno and let him sit for a year or two behind a proven NFL starter.

I love Kaepernick but I think SF will miss Alex' experience in the playoffs. Smith is as good as all 3 of our current QBs. We're a 10 win team w/him and Andy's play calling. 1 exciting year or 2 while our fresh draft pick waits. Cool.