*****Trade analysis superthread 2013*****

[Dante84]

Should I trade Welker straight up for L. McCoy? Its a 3wr, 2rb, 1flx PPR league and I'm stacked at WR (Wayne, Bowe, Nelson, D. Jackson, Sanders, Thompkins) but weak at RB (Bush, Sproles, Bernard, and Miller).

I hate to lose Welker's upside, but I can match his point totals from one of the back ups. McCoy would start at Flex, pushing Bowe to the bench. Not a bad back up.

The other guy has P. Manning, which is why the trade is being discussed.

[The Bad Guy]

Originally Posted by Dante84

Should I trade Welker straight up for L. McCoy? Its a 3wr, 2rb, 1flx PPR league and I'm stacked at WR (Wayne, Bowe, Nelson, D. Jackson, Sanders, Thompkins) but weak at RB (Bush, Sproles, Bernard, and Miller).

I hate to lose Welker's upside, but I can match his point totals from one of the back ups. McCoy would start at Flex, pushing Bowe to the bench. Not a bad back up.

The other guy has P. Manning, which is why the trade is being discussed.

McCoy is going to finish as the 2nd best fantasy RB behind AP.

Do it.

[Sure-Oz]

Originally Posted by The Bad Guy

McCoy is going to finish as the 2nd best fantasy RB behind AP.

Do it.

I got Mccoy 7th in my draft, I felt like i won the damn lottery when he fell that far.

[Chiefshrink]

Originally Posted by Sure-Oz

I got Mccoy 7th in my draft, I felt like i won the damn lottery when he fell that far.

Damn straight you did and KEEP HIM until the defenses in the league start to make adjustments to Kelly's O and until that happens which may not even be this year McCoy assuming he stays healthy will make you wealthy !!!

[Chiefshrink]

Originally Posted by The Bad Guy

McCoy is going to finish as the 2nd best fantasy RB behind AP.

Do it.

AP had one big run of 78 yds. The other 17 attempts he actually lost a yard with a total rushing amount of 77yds. Defenses will really stack the box big time against him until Ponder proves he is a passing threat.

I get your point, but he won't do this year what he did last year IMO. I see him between 1400-1600 at best this year which is still very good.

[Chiefshrink]

Originally Posted by Dante84

Should I trade Welker straight up for L. McCoy? Its a 3wr, 2rb, 1flx PPR league and I'm stacked at WR (Wayne, Bowe, Nelson, D. Jackson, Sanders, Thompkins) but weak at RB (Bush, Sproles, Bernard, and Miller).

I hate to lose Welker's upside, but I can match his point totals from one of the back ups. McCoy would start at Flex, pushing Bowe to the bench. Not a bad back up.

The other guy has P. Manning, which is why the trade is being discussed.

Tough one. However, McCoy will get a tad more touches and the way Kelly runs this O it is hard to just focus on McCoy and neutralize him so I see him continuing to have big games. Manning's boy is Welker and he will run that well dry and I trust Manning's targeting him.

Stay with Welker I say until you see Shady continue his success then do the deal. Also see if you can pick up J Bell the handcuff RB to Bush. Bush is already hurting even after a good game and it's just a matter of time IMO until Bush pusses out with injuries.