Is Aaron Rodgers GROSSLY overrated?

[Jewish Rabbi]

Originally Posted by tk13

I wouldn't go that far. There aren't many guys out there with his ability, which is why I hate when people compare other QBs to him. You could find posts comparing Geno to him, which is ridiculous. His release his off the charts fast, and his throw velocity is ridiculous. Just the mechanics of his ability are amazing. The ball comes out of his hand different than other guys. I still don't think there's been any QB the last 25 years play better than he did during that Super Bowl run, and then that following season where they went 15-1 or whatever it was.

You're telling me those 30 yard jump balls to Jordy where the defender ends up on his ass aren't luck? Okay.

[Valiant]

Originally Posted by Jewish Rabbi

You're telling me those 30 yard jump balls to Jordy where the defender ends up on his ass aren't luck? Okay.

So he has been lucky 10x more than any other QB in that time frame? That is weird luck. I guess Peyton should thank his stars for him being so lucky so often when it comes to completion percentage and deep throws also.