My final Geno thread before the draft

[patteeu]

Originally Posted by O.city

Looking at the votes, I'm surprised as some of the no votes that they won't be pissed after recent vehement arguments

You shouldn't be. The drooling fanatics are almost all on the Geno-or-bust side. Most of the Geno skeptics are open to the possibility that Reid/Dorsey will see something they think they can work with.

[O.city]

Obviously we have some here who don't completely understand bpa.


And RunKC, is Tyler Wilson a franchise qb?

[BossChief]

Let me pose a question?

Which usage of resources is worse?

A) spending a first, second and third round pick on a solid game managing qb AND a potential franchise quarterback prospect

Or

B) spending 2 firsts, 2 seconds AND two thirds on the offensive line...with one second and one third being backups?

[O.city]

Originally Posted by BossChief

Let me pose a question?

Which usage of resources is worse?

A) spending a first, second and third round pick on a solid game managing qb AND a potential franchise quarterback prospect

Or

B) spending 2 firsts, 2 seconds AND two thirds on the offensive line...with one second and one third being backups?

As bad as the anti qb guys are some of you guys are getting close.


All those previous picks on the ol were made by the previous regime. It doesn't matter at this point if the new regime doesn't think they are good enough

[B14ckmon]

Originally Posted by BossChief

Let me pose a question?

Which usage of resources is worse?

A) spending a first, second and third round pick on a solid game managing qb AND a potential franchise quarterback prospect

Or

B) spending 2 firsts, 2 seconds AND two thirds on the offensive line...with one second and one third being backups?

Does it really mater when B is the way your team is going?

[O.city]

So your ok with him giving 100 million dollars to a guy he doesn't think is a franchise player?

[Messier]

Originally Posted by O.city

So your ok with him giving 100 million dollars to a guy he doesn't think is a franchise player?

Vick already restructured. He's nor gonna make nearly 100 million.

[O.city]

Originally Posted by Messier

Vick already restructured. He's nor gonna make nearly 100 million.

That's a cop out dude. Doesn't dismiss the fact that Reid gave him te contract. He wasn't restructured by Reid

[Messier]

Originally Posted by O.city

That's a cop out dude. Doesn't dismiss the fact that Reid gave him te contract. He wasn't restructured by Reid

Does Reid handle contracts?

[Messier]

I think the term "franchise quarterback" is being thrown around pretty loosely. There aren't even that many in the NFL.

[O.city]

Originally Posted by Messier

I think the term "franchise quarterback" is being thrown around pretty loosely. There aren't even that many in the NFL.

There are quite a few franchise qbs. There aren't many elite qbs.

[O.city]

So you think Reid had nothing to do with Vick getting the deal he got?

If he didn't view his as a franchise QB, the Gm signed him to a deal of that caliber without the ok from his HC?

[stonedstooge]

Originally Posted by O.city

So you think Reid had nothing to do with Vick getting the deal he got?

If he didn't view his as a franchise QB, the Gm signed him to a deal of that caliber without the ok from his HC?

That's how I'd handle it/Pioli

[Messier]

Originally Posted by O.city

So you think Reid had nothing to do with Vick getting the deal he got?

If he didn't view his as a franchise QB, the Gm signed him to a deal of that caliber without the ok from his HC?

I'm sure Reid said we need to sign Vick. I don't think he came up with amount. Reid still likes Vick. Before he restructured, I thought Vick was the frontrunner to come here. Reid had some glowing words about him.

So, yes, I'll take back Vick, Reid thought he was a franchise QB.

[O.city]

Joeckel doesn't fit Reid's "LT" players, based on history.