|
|
09-19-2012, 10:57 AM | #1 |
In BB I trust
Join Date: May 2003
Location: Boston, Mass.
Casino cash: $10029808
|
The movies will stand or fall on their own. The movies don't have to precisely track the books, no matter what the purists think. If he adds new material (which he CLEARLY is doing, since there's all kinds of stuff that happen but are completely off-scene in the book but are being shown in the movie), then that's fine as long as the tone and tenor is consistent with Tolkien's world.
Changes only bother me when they literally make no sense. The Witch King breaking Gandalf's staff and blowing him off his horse in the extended version of RotK REALLY pisses me off. It makes no sense and seems to show that the Witch King is clearly more powerful than Gandalf. WTF is that about? But otherwise, judge the movies for what they are. Jackson has earned a fair bit of latitude I think, given past success, and I hope he makes three really great, enjoyable movies.
__________________
"I love signature blocks on the Internet. I get to put whatever the hell I want in quotes, pick a pretend author, and bang, it's like he really said it." George Washington |
Posts: 43,125
|
09-19-2012, 11:08 AM | #2 | |
Starter
Join Date: Mar 2005
Casino cash: $7729487
|
Quote:
replacing glorfindel with arwen burned my ass. |
|
Posts: 777
|
09-20-2012, 08:58 AM | #3 |
In BB I trust
Join Date: May 2003
Location: Boston, Mass.
Casino cash: $10029808
|
Why? Look, I really like Glorfindel. He's a very cool character. In fact, for years I've had this idea that in the far recesses of his mind, during the Council of Elrond, when Gandalf is saying "even if you were to give us an Elf Lord of your house, he could not open the road by the power that is in him", Frodo was over there thinking "shut up Gandalf -- I love Merry and Pippin, but I'll take Glorfindel thanksallthesame." But the plot is already complicated enough to squeeze it into the timeframe he had, letting Arwen do it reduces the number of characters in the series and also introduces a strong female character to help connect with the women in the audience. Let's face it, women do NOTHING in Lord of the Rings. Nothing on-stage anyway. What Arwen does is also consistent with Tolkien's other works, so it's not absurd in the context of his world either. Luthien faced off Sauron (with Huan doing the grunt work) and then Morgoth himself in the Lay of Lethian. Frankly, all she really does is help partially heal Frodo (very consistent with Luthian and Arwen's own father (Elrond) and grandmother (Galadriel)'s abilities, and then steal a bit of Gandalf's thunder with the horses. Would I personally have preferred to just stay true to the books? Yes. But I get why he made the changes and frankly, they're just not that big a deal to me.
__________________
"I love signature blocks on the Internet. I get to put whatever the hell I want in quotes, pick a pretend author, and bang, it's like he really said it." George Washington |
Posts: 43,125
|
09-20-2012, 09:29 AM | #4 |
Go Beavers!
Join Date: Jan 2001
Location: Warshington
Casino cash: $5088243
|
I have a friend that absolutely loathes the LOTR trilogy simply because they cut out the Tom Bombadil section of FOTR. I love the books too but I'm not that big of a purist.
|
Posts: 14,504
|
09-20-2012, 10:38 AM | #5 | |
In BB I trust
Join Date: May 2003
Location: Boston, Mass.
Casino cash: $10029808
|
Quote:
Ditto, though my friend doesn't "loathe" the trilogy, he's just really upset about leaving out Tom Bombadil. As if he's integral to the story or would be worth the extra half-hour they'd need (at least) to cover all that stuff. Seriously, what was Jackson supposed to do? Be completely faithful and make three five hour movies??
__________________
"I love signature blocks on the Internet. I get to put whatever the hell I want in quotes, pick a pretend author, and bang, it's like he really said it." George Washington |
|
Posts: 43,125
|
09-20-2012, 02:27 PM | #6 | |
Veteran
Join Date: Mar 2009
Location: Houston, TX area
Casino cash: $8162083
|
Quote:
|
|
Posts: 1,574
|
09-20-2012, 09:29 PM | #7 | |
World's Best Boss
Join Date: Jul 2007
Location: Bronco Country
Casino cash: $5074654
|
Quote:
/fanboi |
|
Posts: 18,458
|
09-26-2012, 01:46 PM | #8 | |
In BB I trust
Join Date: May 2003
Location: Boston, Mass.
Casino cash: $10029808
|
Quote:
You're absolutely right -- Eowyn gets one shining moment in the book, and in the movie. But aside from that, there's very little that women do in the book that is particularly active. Galadriel's contributions are absolutely invaluable, but they're indirect and/or off-screen. He wanted a stronger female character. He ditched Glorfindel to give Arwen more screen time. Hardly worth going bananas over.
__________________
"I love signature blocks on the Internet. I get to put whatever the hell I want in quotes, pick a pretend author, and bang, it's like he really said it." George Washington |
|
Posts: 43,125
|
09-27-2012, 07:30 AM | #9 | |
Hey Loochy, I'm hooome!
Join Date: Oct 2008
Location: PooPooKaKaPeePeeShire
Casino cash: $700397
|
Quote:
__________________
Hey Loochy, I'm hoooome! |
|
Posts: 41,158
|
09-19-2012, 02:46 PM | #10 |
YOU take YOUR seat
Join Date: Nov 2007
Casino cash: $795105
|
I'm excited for it. I should have a LOTR marathon before this comes out.
__________________
|
Posts: 34,521
|
09-19-2012, 02:49 PM | #11 |
The Boom Boom Room
Join Date: Aug 2000
Location: Far Beyond Comprehension
Casino cash: $-527187
|
that's 12 to 13 hours out of the day
__________________
|
Posts: 42,490
|
09-20-2012, 09:55 AM | #12 |
Ain't no relax!
Join Date: Sep 2005
Casino cash: $868919
|
I really liked Bombadil in the book. But it would have been really hard to project that character into film. He was impossibly confusing and mysterious even in the book. It would have taken 30 minutes of explanation for viewers unfamiliar with the book to understand Tom in the film...
__________________
|
Posts: 48,232
|
09-20-2012, 10:30 AM | #13 | ||
Got swag?
Join Date: Aug 2003
Location: Madison, MS
Casino cash: $10008287
|
Quote:
Quote:
__________________
|
||
Posts: 11,847
|
09-20-2012, 11:05 AM | #14 | |
World's finest morphius
Join Date: Aug 2000
Casino cash: $6515027
|
Quote:
|
|
Posts: 25,996
|
09-20-2012, 02:54 PM | #15 | |
Ain't no relax!
Join Date: Sep 2005
Casino cash: $868919
|
Quote:
The whole "Kinda omnipotent tree hugger Cheshire cat lumberjack with a penchant for silly poetry" really doesn't fit with the rest of the story...
__________________
|
|
Posts: 48,232
|
|
|