Survivor: Caramoan - Fans vs. Favorites

[Aries Walker]

I really hope Cochran wins. He is hilarious.

And Malcolm did some serious sixth-sense spur-of-the-moment figuring there, to not only realize they had sniffed him out, but to then quickly talk Reynold out of his immunity idol when he had a perfectly good one himself. If not for Eddie thinking he had a brain or a good idea, he would have taken out Andrea and completely flipped the game.

[Fairplay]

Originally Posted by Aries Walker

I really hope Cochran wins. He is hilarious.

And Malcolm did some serious sixth-sense spur-of-the-moment figuring there, to not only realize they had sniffed him out, but to then quickly talk Reynold out of his immunity idol when he had a perfectly good one himself. If not for Eddie thinking he had a brain or a good idea, he would have taken out Andrea and completely flipped the game.

I want Cochran to win also, every time he talks he makes he chuckle.

He's not physical, I can't see him winning anymore immunity's unless the show comes up with puzzle type games to solve. A non-threatening player, he can go under the radar for quite some time I think.

[MagicHef]

I want to know if Reynold can figure out who voted for him.

[NJChiefsFan]

Originally Posted by MagicHef

I want to know if Reynold can figure out who voted for him.

I'm curious if Philip still would have made the speech if they were voting for Malcolm

Cochran is making me laugh a lot more this year and dawn is actually fooling people with her lying

[MagicHef]

Originally Posted by NJChiefsFan

I'm curious if Philip still would have made the speech if they were voting for Malcolm

Cochran is making me laugh a lot more this year and dawn is actually fooling people with her lying

Yeah, I was thinking that Philip was an idiot for what he was saying, now I'm wondering if it was intentional.

I've always liked Cochran, he's like a young red headed Woody Allen.

[Sfeihc]

I thought for a minute before going to tribal that Stealth R Us could have flushed Reynold's idol and voted Malcolm out last night. Andrea crapped her pants and ruined the chances for that.

[Chiefnj2]

Why did Malcolm vote for Reynold?

And what's the deal with super secret agent man being the first out of the water torture competition. Didn't they teach him how to deal with water boarding?

[MagicHef]

Originally Posted by Chiefnj2

Why did Malcolm vote for Reynold?

And what's the deal with super secret agent man being the first out of the water torture competition. Didn't they teach him how to deal with water boarding?

I think Philip's speech scared him, he wanted to look like he was in with the favorites still while keeping himself safe. The last thing he heard from Andrea was that the guys were voting for Reynold and the girls were voting for Eddie.

[NJChiefsFan]

Originally Posted by MagicHef

I think Philip's speech scared him, he wanted to look like he was in with the favorites still while keeping himself safe. The last thing he heard from Andrea was that the guys were voting for Reynold and the girls were voting for Eddie.

If his plan was to still look like he was in then standing up and acting not only sure but cocky about snuffing out the Favorites plan wasn't a great idea.

[buddha]

When is anybody going to see that Dawn is the snake of all snakes?

[Aries Walker]

I don't know, but they should. This past episode was the third time in a row that someone let her in on a perfectly good plan, and she went a-runnin' immediately to Philip and ratted them out. The first two people got voted out; Malcolm got off lucky by having his plan submarined and losing an ally and an immunity idol.

I can't stand Dawn. She's the kind of terrible player who has no chance of winning but no one wants to get rid of because they're "nice" and non-threatening. She's also melodramatic and irritating. Ugh.

[MagicHef]

Dawn is a snake? Why, for staying loyal to the people she has an alliance with? I'm pretty sure she didn't make any of those idiots blab their plan to her, they just couldn't help themselves. Any of them should have seen that telling Dawn was at best risky and at worst stupid, not because of who Dawn is, but because of her alliance.

I think Dawn has a pretty good shot at winning actually. Better than Malcolm, Eddie, Reynold or Philip, certainly.

[NJChiefsFan]

Originally Posted by MagicHef

Dawn is a snake? Why, for staying loyal to the people she has an alliance with? I'm pretty sure she didn't make any of those idiots blab their plan to her, they just couldn't help themselves. Any of them should have seen that telling Dawn was at best risky and at worst stupid, not because of who Dawn is, but because of her alliance.

I think Dawn has a pretty good shot at winning actually. Better than Malcolm, Eddie, Reynold or Philip, certainly.

My friend said the same thing about Dawn that the others said and I don't get it. Dawn is just staying loyal to her alliance. Just because people assume Dawn will flip and run with anyone who will talk nice to her doesn't mean she is a bitch for not following along. I like that she is sticking with a plan that she believes in.

[Aries Walker]

I think Malcolm and Reynold both have very good chances of winning. If the Strong Guys alliance gets picked off, whoever is the last one left has a really good chance of making an immunity run, and Malcolm has an idol to back it up. Even Philip has a fairly good chance - he's wacky and this Stealth R Us thing is one step short of mental illness, but he's keeping a strong alliance together, is really good at challenges (especially for being his age), and the only person he really infuriated missed being on the jury. His chances are a lot better now than they were three or so weeks ago.

Eddie, of course, is dead man walking.

[NJChiefsFan]

Originally Posted by Aries Walker

I think Malcolm and Reynold both have very good chances of winning. If the Strong Guys alliance gets picked off, whoever is the last one left has a really good chance of making an immunity run, and Malcolm has an idol to back it up. Even Philip has a fairly good chance - he's wacky and this Stealth R Us thing is one step short of mental illness, but he's keeping a strong alliance together, is really good at challenges (especially for being his age), and the only person he really infuriated missed being on the jury. His chances are a lot better now than they were three or so weeks ago.

Eddie, of course, is dead man walking.

It's unreal how Eddie is concerned not just about keeping Reynold as a member of his alliance but as a friend. If the choice was put in his hands in a final 4, I don't think he would vote out Reynold, even if it meant him having a better chance in the final 3. I have to admit Phillip has impressed me a little bit this season, especially in challenges.