Geno Smith vs Alex Smith - It's on.

[Hammock Parties]

It's on now. Geno Smith is probably going to be starting for the Jets this season.

Alex Smith will be the Chiefs QB for the forseeable future. If he's a success, we'll probably get five good years out of him.

So who's gonna win more NFL games over that time period?

Put your ten pounders on the table and make a vote

Alex: 11 wins
Geno: 8 wins

[Hammock Parties]

Originally Posted by scott free

Playoff wins or a super bowl, what is it you expect? He beat good teams in the playoffs with frisco
.

No. He beat one team in the playoffs. TEAM. Not plural.

Sunshine. Ass. Dog.

[BossChief]

I really hope Alex Smith continues to develop the lacking parts of his game and learns to go for the throat when he needs to.

I hate being pessimistic and want to homer up like some of you here, but I've been sold the snake oil too many times...

[RealSNR]

Originally Posted by mattschiefs

Ok this is pointless I'll go to anther site this I thought was a site for Chiefs fans not geno ass kissers so I'll do you a favor and leave

But before I go let me say that I find you people to be anything BUT chiefs fans. You bash a QB who has come to KC and win. 5-0 and instead of being happy you whine and cry that the QB isn't who you wanted. You give all Chiefs fans a bad name. Telling people to get aids Real classy real classy. It's real sad when the 49ers fans on here act more like Chiefs fans then You people. The fact is the FACTS don't support your opinion. You can't do better in the w-l department in 5 games then 5-0 that's what Alex Smith has done yet you people crap all over him. The chiefs didn't draft Geno Smith TO BAD SO SAD. He wasn't the right choice You wanted to go from turnover machine to Turnover machine and I'm the stupid one ok. I will go spend my time doing something more productive then continue dealing with internet tough guys and know it alls when the facts don't support them. Have a nice day.

[BossChief]

Originally Posted by mattschiefs

Ok this is pointless I'll go to anther site this I thought was a site for Chiefs fans not geno ass kissers so I'll do you a favor and leave

But before I go let me say that I find you people to be anything BUT chiefs fans. You bash a QB who has come to KC and win. 5-0 and instead of being happy you whine and cry that the QB isn't who you wanted. You give all Chiefs fans a bad name. Telling people to get aids Real classy real classy. It's real sad when the 49ers fans on here act more like Chiefs fans then You people. The fact is the FACTS don't support your opinion. You can't do better in the w-l department in 5 games then 5-0 that's what Alex Smith has done yet you people crap all over him. The chiefs didn't draft Geno Smith TO BAD SO SAD. He wasn't the right choice You wanted to go from turnover machine to Turnover machine and I'm the stupid one ok. I will go spend my time doing something more productive then continue dealing with internet tough guys and
know it alls when the facts don't support them. Have a nice day.

Www.chiefscoalition.com

Do me a favor when you get there, will ya?

Tell omahacolt that Matt Cassel still isn't a franchise quarterback.

[Sweet Daddy Hate]

Originally Posted by BossChief

Www.chiefscoalition.com

Do me a favor when you get there, will ya?

Tell omahacolt that Matt Cassel still isn't a franchise quarterback.

[Easy 6]

Originally Posted by mattschiefs

Ok this is pointless I'll go to anther site this I thought was a site for Chiefs fans not geno ass kissers so I'll do you a favor and leave

But before I go let me say that I find you people to be anything BUT chiefs fans. You bash a QB who has come to KC and win. 5-0 and instead of being happy you whine and cry that the QB isn't who you wanted. You give all Chiefs fans a bad name. Telling people to get aids Real classy real classy. It's real sad when the 49ers fans on here act more like Chiefs fans then You people. The fact is the FACTS don't support your opinion. You can't do better in the w-l department in 5 games then 5-0 that's what Alex Smith has done yet you people crap all over him. The chiefs didn't draft Geno Smith TO BAD SO SAD. He wasn't the right choice You wanted to go from turnover machine to Turnover machine and I'm the stupid one ok. I will go spend my time doing something more productive then continue dealing with internet tough guys and know it alls when the facts don't support them. Have a nice day.

Now now now, calm down... i thought you were showing promise early on.

But this hissy fit isnt helping, you cant move mountains in a day... take the night off and come back aware of the fact that your strong opinion probably isnt changing any minds and just have fun with it.

Good night...

[ViperVisor]

Originally Posted by scott free

I'm curious as to what its going to take to get some of you off Axl's back... a couple of playoff wins this year, a super bowl this year?

Seriously, whats it gonna take... yes, Geno loves to air it out and has looked excellent for a rookie... but just because he has a "sexier" style of play does not make him a more effective QB.

How are we really supposed to compare these two guys who are in such different spots in their careers? Is this more about Fisher vs Geno and where they were picked, or is it really all about comparing two vastly different playing styles and deciding who looks better in a bikini?

Can Geno one day lead the jets to the promised land? he's certainly looking capable of it one of these days... does he stand a better chance of winning in the playoffs right now or next year than Axl? c'mon, he just doesnt and thats gotta be a major reason why we didnt take him, our core talent is getting too old to wait on a kid to shake his growing pains... if you want to win NOW he simply wasnt the right choice.

While Geno is growing up, we're winning football games and building a winning tradition, the kind of tradition that can have us very much respectable and in the thick of the hunt for the next decade.

And no, Alex isnt going to be a part of that entire decade, the next guy will be up soon enough, dont believe it? just look at what Reid and Dorsey are already doing, leaving no stone unturned and finding gems all over the damn place... they arent settling for OK.

Anyway, i hope this dies down one day and everyone can enjoy the fact that KC is FINALLY making a name for itself as a winner.

Thanks for a POV and some substance vs. the name calling.

KC was in a strange/unlucky spot when they bottomed out.

The team was not lacking in some great talent.

49ers young core players back when they had the #1 pick.

Complete busts

Kwame Harris
Brandon Lloyd *Got a 3rd round pick for him. Never seemed commited. Got his money from WAS and proved that. Bursts back onto the scene in 2010.
Derrick Hamilton
Rashaun Woods
Justin Smiley *OK OG I guess. MIA signed him in 08
Shawntae Spencer *OK CB
Anthony Adams *OK player I guess, hard to tell with inside DL
Andre Carter *Pro bowl, production drops, hurt, then moved to 3-4, not good, Leaves vis FA.
Eric Johnson *always hurt, married Jessica Simpson
Kevan Barlow *2 more years then out of the NFL
Mike Rumph
Julian Peterson *Franchise tag in 04. Achilles tear. Meh 05, Leaves vis FA


49ers in 2005 had no option other than a project QB and rebuild.

[BossChief]

I wonder how things would have been different if the 49ers had taken Aaron Rodgers first overall and Alex Smith fell to the Packers and sat behind Favre for 3 years.

[Easy 6]

Originally Posted by ViperVisor

Thanks for a POV and some substance vs. the name calling.

KC was in a strange/unlucky spot when they bottomed out.

The team was not lacking in some great talent.

49ers young core players back when they had the #1 pick.

Complete busts

Kwame Harris
Brandon Lloyd *Got a 3rd round pick for him. Never seemed commited. Got his money from WAS and proved that. Bursts back onto the scene in 2010.
Derrick Hamilton
Rashaun Woods
Justin Smiley *OK OG I guess. MIA signed him in 08
Shawntae Spencer *OK CB
Anthony Adams *OK player I guess, hard to tell with inside DL
Andre Carter *Pro bowl, production drops, hurt, then moved to 3-4, not good, Leaves vis FA.
Eric Johnson *always hurt, married Jessica Simpson
Kevan Barlow *2 more years then out of the NFL
Mike Rumph
Julian Peterson *Franchise tag in 04. Achilles tear. Meh 05, Leaves vis FA


49ers in 2005 had no option other than a project QB and rebuild.

Yeah, a lot of "bloddy hell!" on that list.

[splatbass]

Originally Posted by the Talking Can

hilarious

you'll always find an excuse

Geno has already shoved the True Fans words up their asses sideways....

He's done nothing of the sort. He's had two good games (against crappy defenses), two spectacularly bad games, and one ok game.

[Sweet Daddy Hate]

Originally Posted by splatbass

He's done nothing of the sort. He's had two good games (against crappy defenses), two spectacularly bad games, and one ok game.

Pretty stellar for 2nd round rook thrown to the fire, yes?

[BossChief]

Also, I love it when n00bs come here (a site with thousands of differing opinions that is loosely moderated) and get all butthurt right away when a few people have a different perspective towards the team than them.

I can picture this mattchiefs guy typing a lot of words thinking to himself while he types "yeah, they are gonna offer me their wives and daughters for the greatness of my individual perspective" and then they hit submit and get blasted back to the stoneages by fans of the same team that don't see things the exact same way as him.

It must be heart breaking for some of these guys.

[Sweet Daddy Hate]

Originally Posted by BossChief

Also, I love it when n00bs come here (a site with thousands of differing opinions that is loosely moderated) and get all butthurt right away when a few people have a different perspective towards the team than them.

I can picture this mattchiefs guy typing a lot of words thinking to himself while he types "yeah, they are gonna offer me their wives and daughters for the greatness of my individual perspective" and then they hit submit and get blasted back to the stoneages by fans of the same team that don't see things the exact same way as him.

It must be heart breaking for some of these guys.

[Hammock Parties]

What's more likely?

The guy who has raised checking the ball down and leading average scoring offenses to an art form wins a Super Bowl, or the talented kid who is improving by leaps and bounds every game and has three fourth quarter comebacks in five games does it?

Hmmmmm.

[BossChief]

Originally Posted by splatbass

He's done nothing of the sort. He's had two good games (against crappy defenses), two spectacularly bad games, and one ok game.

Alex Smith has thrown almost as many poor passes as the 21 year old rook while facing the #30 pass defense, the #29 pass defense and the # 22 ranked pass defenses in football (with far more talent to work with) defenders just haven't caught the ball like they did on Genos poor throws.