Tom Brady: Greatest ever?

[Hammock Parties]

So he now has four Super Bowls, just like Montana.

He also has the rare distinction of also winning one at the end of his career. Rarely happens to guys his age.

Also has disgusting numbers.

Difference in eras has to be considered, but it's certainly a conversation.

[ChiefsChoke010414]

Originally Posted by Just Passin' By

How is getting to fewer Super Bowls better?

I mentioned Bradshaw as a joke.

But seriously, do you think Bradshaw is a better QB than Favre? He made more Superbowls.

[ChiefsChoke010414]

Originally Posted by jspchief

The Patriots defense has only been "dominant" once in Brady's career. The rest of the time they've been anywhere from decent to mediocre.

By once you mean when they won three Superbowls?

[ShowtimeSBMVP]

Tom Brady in the fourth quarter: 13 of 15 for 124 yards and two touchdowns.

[The Franchise]

Montana. Never lost one and was in an era where his WRs were getting raped by DBs.

[DaneMcCloud]

I hope Tom Brady chokes on Giselle's cock tonight and goes into a coma

['Hamas' Jenkins]

Originally Posted by Dicky McElephant

Montana. Never lost one and was in an era where his WRs were getting raped by DBs.

SSS, but he also never threw a pick in a SB (although a Bengal safety did drop one in the endzone in SB XXIII) and he threw more TDs in four SBs than Brady did in five without a loss.

[jspchief]

Originally Posted by ChiefsChoke010414

By once you mean when they won three Superbowls?

No. I mean 1 year.

[Ragged Robin]

Montana also had the legendary MOMENTS where he won the game, Brady's legacy is mostly off the leg of Adam Vinateri + Spygate+Deflategate

[EPodolak]

I think Tom thinks he's the best, whatever else about him the dood is very tough through adversity.

[ChiefsChoke010414]

Originally Posted by PizzaDoughz

I think the older guys here are a little biased towards older players. I think honestly Brady is better, even if has or has not cheated along the way

I'm not one of the older guys, but I realize this era is a passing era where many QB's are putting up fantasy numbers.

[Jimmya]

As Aikman said "we couldn't have little slot wr's because of bump and run, so it's a different game today."

[tk13]

Originally Posted by Ragged Robin

Montana also had the legendary MOMENTS where he won the game, Brady's legacy is mostly off the leg of Adam Vinateri + Spygate+Deflategate

He just had the biggest 4th quarter comeback in the history of the Super Bowl, against one of the best defenses of this century. That's pretty clutch.

[DaneMcCloud]

Originally Posted by PizzaDoughz

I think the older guys here are a little biased towards older players. I think honestly Brady is better, even if has or has not cheated along the way

Dan Marino would throw for 7,000 yards and 70 TD's with today's rules

[Ragged Robin]

Originally Posted by tk13

Don't forget Montana's greatest achievement, having two of Kansas City's three playoff wins in the last 45 years.

let's not forget he blewout Elway & the donks in the SB

[Buck]

Originally Posted by ChiefsChoke010414

They're not?

Flacco is putting up as many if not more playoff wins than Brady did his first few years in the league. Same with Wilson.

Tom Brady
21-8, 4 championships

Peyton Manning
11-13, 1 championship

Ben Roethlisberger
10-5, 2 championships

Drew Brees
6-5, 1 championship

Joe Flacco
10-5, 1 championship

Kurt Warner
9-4, 1 championship

Russel Wilson
6-2, 1 championship

Eli Manning
8-3, 2 championships

Brad Johnson
4-4, 1 championship

Aaron Rodgers
7-5, 1 championship

I think that covers all of the championships won since Brady was drafted. Nobody even comes close.

Edit: actually don't count Warner. Replace him with Dilfer: 5-1, 1 championship (GOAT win pct)