*** official geno vs the big bad bear thread ***

[SAUTO]

Does he get eaten by something other than clay





You lazy pussies happy now?
Posted via Mobile Device

['Hamas' Jenkins]

Originally Posted by Hootie 2.0

I'm not sure who you're referring to but I like to call them like I see them...

So far this year...Alex Smith has been incredibly boring and a big ball of 'meh.' He's good at leading a running team...but he literally makes no plays with his arm, and is merely good at getting the ball to his backs or tight ends...might as well not even give the guy a receiver.

Geno has flashed, but he's just so inconsistent, and he makes such incredibly dumb plays, that I just don't ever see him becoming a franchise QB...and after all, that is the point, right?

It's kind of like Alex Smith, and Andy Dalton, and Geno Smith, and etc...

All of them win games at times, and look good at times...but they all have those flaws that make you think, "nope, not gonna happen."

and for the last 8 years on this board EVERYONE has wanted to find that Andrew Luck in the draft...and yet we're still debating about Geno Smith?

I mean, come on. Geno, Alex...both have enough flaws that you're never going to win anything meaningful unless you either get copious amounts of Flacco luck or build a totally ELITE team around them (top 3 defense, great OL, great offensive weapons)...

In the last several drafts these are the only QB's that mean anything:

Russell Wilson
Andrew Luck
Colin Kaepernick
Cam Newton

The other guys like Geno? Who gives a shit?

Not referring to you, just the general attitude of the posters who try to contort everything and consequently discredit their beliefs in the process.

I despised the Fisher pick and hated the Smith trade as much as anyone can hate it, but I'm not going to bash the guy when his line causes him to get his teeth kicked in, like the first quarter of the game yesterday.

Similarly, when he makes bad throws the apologists do anything and everything to excuse it, and the same damn thing happens with Geno Smith.

He throws for 300 yards and he's the worst ever instead of him being a 2nd year QB who has shown some things to get excited about and other traits to worry about.

[Hootie]

Originally Posted by 'Hamas' Jenkins

Not referring to you, just the general attitude of the posters who try to contort everything and consequently discredit their beliefs in the process.

I despised the Fisher pick and hated the Smith trade as much as anyone can hate it, but I'm not going to bash the guy when his line causes him to get his teeth kicked in, like the first quarter of the game yesterday.

Similarly, when he makes bad throws the apologists do anything and everything to excuse it, and the same damn thing happens with Geno Smith.

He throws for 300 yards and he's the worst ever instead of him being a 2nd year QB who has shown some things to get excited about and other traits to worry about.

Good points.

I've been moderately impressed with Geno this year and moderately bored with Alex Smith this year, thus far.

[Hootie]

Like, I don't dislike Alex or think he's a bad player or anything like that...

He just BORES me.

[Mr. Laz]

Rex Ryan > Bob Sutton

[warrior]

:

Originally Posted by Marcellus

Geno has that It factor.

And you cant spell SHIT without IT.

[Reerun_KC]

Originally Posted by Mr. Laz

Rex Ryan > Bob Sutton

Drunk Monkey beating off with a cheese grader > Bob Sutton and Candy Reid.