Andy Reid on Mike & Mike: "Alex is our quarterback by the way"

[kcxiv]

Thats the thing, Smith won lose you games, but he will very rarely win you games. He will very very rarely take a game over with his arm. I learned quite a few years back, that in order to win a Superbowl without and Elite QB you have to have an insane defense and have absolutely everything go your way. If they do not happen, you are ****ed. Elite QB's have so much more room for error.

We have seen this over and over and over being a Chiefs fan.

[FloridaMan88]

Originally Posted by kcxiv

Thats the thing, Smith won lose you games, but he will very rarely win you games. He will very very rarely take a game over with his arm. I learned quite a few years back, that in order to win a Superbowl without and Elite QB you have to have an insane defense and have absolutely everything go your way. If they do not happen, you are ****ed. Elite QB's have so much more room for error. We have seen this over and over and over being a Chiefs fan.

Alex Smith basically lost the Tampa and Tennessee games with horrific end zone INT's.

[Rasputin]

Originally Posted by kcxiv

Thats the thing, Smith won lose you games, but he will very rarely win you games. He will very very rarely take a game over with his arm. I learned quite a few years back, that in order to win a Superbowl without and Elite QB you have to have an insane defense and have absolutely everything go your way. If they do not happen, you are ****ed. Elite QB's have so much more room for error.

We have seen this over and over and over being a Chiefs fan.

The Bears had an insane defense as you speak of and were spotted 7 points from kick off with Devin Hester return for a touchdown but Peyton Manning picked that defense apart. Didn't help the Bears that Rex Grossman stepped on their own nuts but Peyton Manning still won the Colts that Super Bowl.