Whos the better QB: Aaron Rodgers or Brett Favre?

[Deberg_1990]

If you had to win 1 game. Who do you take?



As I said higher in the column, if the Packers beat the woebegone playoff contenders tonight, Aaron Rodgers will have an identical record after 100 starts (68-32) as Brett Favre. What’s notable in the comparison between the two quarterbacks is the edge Rodgers has statistically. These numbers include only games each quarterback started, not the mop-up stuff each did before beginning their starting careers:

Player Starts W-L Comp. Att. Pct. Yards TD-Int TD-Int diff. Rating
Rodgers 99 67-32 2,176 3,276 .660 27,193 219-54 +165 107.1
Favre 100 68-32 2,094 3,400 .616 24,079 194-104 +90 89.2

However, in Most Valuable Player awards won by the time of their 100th starts:

Favre: 3
Rodgers: 1

Now, Rodgers may get his second this year, but my point about all of this is a simple one. Even though Rodgers is playing in a different day, with more emphasis on the passing game and (this year) more points of emphasis to make it easier to put up monster numbers in the passing game, Favre was a great player early, and Rodgers has been a great player early, one generation apart. There’s good reason if you’re a Favre fan to say Favre was better, and a good reason today to say Rodgers is better. If you love the Packers, simply count yourself lucky to have had two starting quarterbacks in the past 22 years, and both are likely to go down as all-timers if Rodgers stays healthy.



http://mmqb.si.com/2014/12/08/jj-wat...nfl-week-14/6/

[Chiefs=Champions]

Rodgers. Easily.

[Pepe Silvia]

Rodgers all day everyday. I don't want game ending interceptions.

[WakkaWakka]

Rodgers, no question.

[Jerm]

Rodgers for me too...has everything Favre has plus a lot more mobility and more control over his throws.

[BigMeatballDave]

Is this a serious question?

Rodgers. And it's not close.

[Pablo]

Packers fans luck into back to back HOF QB's.

**** them.

[Jerm]

Originally Posted by Pablo

Packers fans luck into back to back HOF QB's.

**** them.

Indy too....

[Pablo]

Originally Posted by Jerm

Indy too....

Yep.

They're the Colts of the NFC. **** them.

[Pepe Silvia]

Originally Posted by Pablo

Packers fans luck into back to back HOF QB's.

**** them.

**** you Howard.

[Buehler445]

Originally Posted by BigMeatballDave

Is this a serious question?

Rodgers. And it's not close.

This. By a lot. Even if he plays as long as Favre did, I bet he doesn't own the INT record.

[ThaVirus]

Id take Rodgers over any QB in the history of ever. The only one that I'd even contemplate is Peyton.

[Mr_Tomahawk]

Tyler Bray

[ThaVirus]

I never liked Favre, for the record.

I think he's the worst of the best QBs of all time. The Emmitt Smith of QBs.

[Pepe Silvia]

Originally Posted by ThaVirus

I never liked Favre, for the record.

I think he's the worst of the best QBs of all time. The Emmitt Smith of QBs.

His ego cost us many games, always had to be the hero.