Quote:
Originally Posted by Wallcrawler
Refuted.
I'm sorry, but wah wahhh I didn't have a hall of fame qb in the game I was STILL expected to win, but I made terrible calls and choked in, is not a valid excuse.
Are you going on record saying that NO coach alive could have taken those Eagles teams to a Superbowl victory because McNabb was not a HOF qb? Just the franchise leader in all passing categories. Top 5 statistical qb at the time.
Not even a coach who could balance run and pass, and manage the clock and take advantage of that ferocious defense?
That's a surface of the sun temperature take if so.
You probably also think it wasn't John Harbaughs fault that the Ravens lost the AFCCG in their house this year as well, despite abandoning the leagues best running game.
He just doesn't have a hall of fame qb guys. He can't be held responsible for a shitty gameplan and worse execution.
|
The Eagles should thank Andy for them winning a Super Bowl. Foles was drafted by Andy. Pederson was brought up under Andy.
Andy Reid even gave Rosman info to draft Jalen Hurts.
Andy never had his star QB and that’s the difference. This year more than proves that theory with how the offense played.
Your opinion on Andy is bizarre bc you need a star QB to win a ring. 90% of the time it’s the same guys. Look at the AFC for proof of that. Mahomes, Brady, Manning and Big Ben are the AFC Champions in all but 2 years since 2002.
McNabb was overrated as hell and was made to look better by Andy’s scheme.