Who would you rather have on the roster - Toney or Moore?
 

For this exercise, you need to pick one or the other. Cutting them both is not an option.

Poll

Toney is more talented, but is a risk to make major negative plays.

Moore will just do nothing, but can also make negative plays (though unlikely because he won’t do anything at all).

Probably Toney because he could (though also unlikely) pull his head out of his ass someday.

Toney is borderline reeruned and is a liability but he has the ability to make game changing plays.

Skyy Moore just straight up sucks.

So as a choice between the two I'd keep Toney, but I'd rather we hit on a UDFA that allows us to get rid of both of them.

At least Toney has some special teams value

Anyone who says "Moore" in this thread needs a lobotomy.

Tough choice... but I'll go with the unpopular take and say Moore.

He's younger, doesn't have an injury history, and has contributed slightly more offensively.

Shit in one hand wish in another when it comes to Toney. He'd be the better keep if he were ever able to stay healthy but he just doesn't

No.

Fire them both into the sun.

I think along the same lines as you, but he can't catch the ball. And not only does he drop the ball, he tends to tip it up in the air for interceptions.

He also seems like a bit of a headcase.

I'd still rather have Toney.

Probably the best choice.

Which is funny because I accidentally voted for Moore in the poll. :shake:

Sky has never had a game like this.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QuD4z9FltWE

There really should’ve been an option to cut both but you have to have unprotected sex with an electric pencil sharpener.

Man, I’d be conflicted.

Moore. He at least will be a professional but I hope they are both gone.

I'd rather we kept both Toney and Skyy than have a dick small enough to do that.

There is a 10% chance things click for Moore this year and he becomes a serviceable slot WR.

There is a 99% chance Toney gets hurt after 2 games and becomes a twitter distraction.