Picard. Easily. By a country F'ing mile.

Unreal all you Picard lovers...He was ok...but dude couldnt fight, and wasnt near the pimp or tactician Kirk was.

Shatner has to be first
Picard a close second
Sisko because of Bjorian mystism


Didn't like Archer or Janeway. We never saw Pike in action.

All the temp captains....James T. Kirk the first was cool. Spock was and always will be the baddest captain. No human can touch his badassness.

When the shit hits the fan...go get Spock.

Picard with shatner/kirk a distant second.

Spock Vs. Data, who wins?

http://t2.gstatic.com/images?q=tbn:A...jTEyN3wUSaFffHhttp://t2.gstatic.com/images?q=tbn:A...Eh17Q15W1YN2yG
-
I vote T'pol I think she was an honorary Captain for an episode.
Ok fine..
Shatner Because it just has to be that way
Picard Is Deff a close 2nd.

But I do agree with the comment if the Sh1T hit the fan I want Spock coming for me with Data a close second.

Sisko wasn't a ladies man (never liked Cassidy that much) but the dude won a ****ing war and was a religious icon to an entire planet.

Spock

But only Sisko got Kirk's autograph!!

Now that's just bad ass.

Over the years I've changed. First it was Kirk, then Picard, now it's probably Sisko because he has the most interesting character arc.

This is wrong.

Spock was promoted to the rank of Captain by Star Trek V or VI.

Shatner/Kirk is the best character. But my vote is Picard because I LOVED that shit when I was a kid. It stuck. But I fully acknowledge that Shatner is where it is at.

1.) Picard
2.) Kirk/Shatner
3.) Kirk/Pine
4.) Sisko
5.) Janeway
6.) Archer
DNQ.) Pike

1. Picard, Kirk

3. Sisko



The new Kirk won major points for the bar scene in the latest Star Trek.