|
Andy Reid with 2nd Most Playoff Wins in NFL History
(https://www.chiefsplanet.com/BB/showthread.php?t=352456)
Andy Reid with 2nd Most Playoff Wins in NFL History
Only 5 behind Belichick, who is currently unemployed and won't win a playoff game anytime soon.
<blockquote class="twitter-tweet"><p lang="en" dir="ltr">Big Red now ranks 2nd in NFL history for total playoff wins among head coaches‼️ <a href="https://t.co/TR7Bgn6whO">pic.twitter.com/TR7Bgn6whO</a></p>— Kansas City Chiefs (@Chiefs) <a href="https://twitter.com/Chiefs/status/1760684560499769392?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw">February 22, 2024</a></blockquote> <script async src="https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js" charset="utf-8"></script> |
Didn't realize he was within 5. He's definitely not hanging it up til he has that record.
|
Once he gets the record this may be untouchable for a very long time.
The only ones with a shot are shanahan and mcvay. Not so sure mcvay will put all the years in. And both guys need to be absolutely dominant for a few decades to even have a shot |
Belichick is a fraud
|
Still amazing that some dumbshits were against hiring Andy…
https://pbs.twimg.com/media/GG8tcNAa...jpg&name=large |
Receipts just keep being dealt. Gotta love it!
|
Quote:
|
Also, that is insane. I had no idea Reid was so close. These last two Super Bowl did wonders for his legacy in the long run: 7 playoff wins combined. Took him from #3 to striking distance of #1.
Even if we only average 1.5 playoff wins per season, he could take the top spot in four years. If he can keep up the Mahomes average of 2.5 playoff wins per season, he could tie it up in two years. Something else that stands out, Reid is 70 regular season wins behind Shula but 7 postseason wins ahead. This run with Mahomes has been dynamite. |
Quote:
Right now the Chiefs are 24-21 all time in the playoffs. Before Mahomes became the starterr they were 9-18. |
Quote:
I’m not going to go back and look, but I want to say that we were around the middle of the pack in regular season win percentage prior to Mahomes. A CPer posted that we’re like #6 or #7 now after updating. We had 8 AFC West titles before Mahomes compared to 15 for the Broncos, Raiders and Chargers each. Now we’ve got 16, the rest still have 15 ROFL We had one Super Bowl win. Now we’ve got four, which is more than anyone in our division (Raiders and Broncos have three a piece, Chargers have zero lol) All in just six short years. |
He's also only 71 wins from most wins all time by a HC. That's why the retirement rumors were always dumb.
Andy is 3 years at most from the playoff record and 7 seasons at his current streak. He's going for it and he's got the best QB ever |
We'll have Andy for a couple more years. Yay!
|
Quote:
A HOF caliber coach can only get you so far if you have a mid tier QB in Alex Smith. Honestly, some people (Wallcrawler) STILL refuse to give Andy the benefit of the doubt even after a couple SB wins. |
Quote:
“Older coaches are tired of the grind and are retiring” is a college football narrative… and is not applicable to the NFL. Belichick and Pete Carroll want to keep coaching… they were both forced out. |
With the back-to-back titles we're also sitting at 7 consecutive playoff wins. The record is 10.
|
Quote:
Or is that the early 2000s Patriots where they missed the playoffs entirely one year, thereby preserving their “streak”? Put an asterisk next to that one too. |
Quote:
|
Andy deserves all of the accolades. He's had success with 2 different franchises with a bunch of different qbs.
Belichick is a fruad who couldn't cut it without Brady. He is a grump who would get Tom Brady coffee every morning. The only coach I would put above Andy Reid is Bill Walsh and that's because Walsh designed the offense that we use today. |
Quote:
|
Quote:
I'm still putting Walsh as number 1. Reid is absolutely number 2. |
How do we feel about Joe Gibbs? Dude won three Super Bowls with three different starting QBs.
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
Reid only needs 64 wins to be the all time holder. Thats 5 year...6 max. I agree that he will stay and try for this. |
Quote:
|
Shocking development: Best quarterback to ever play the game landing in notorious multi-franchise playoff choker's lap leads to massive post season success.
|
Quote:
Hasn't Belichick gone to NINE Super Bowls? How the hell is he only 5 ahead of Andy? I guess Andy's gone to 5 now, right? But damn, that's just barely half as many. I really assumed Belichick had put that record firmly out of reach. |
Quote:
Look at the polls/reactions around here when we hired him. CP is a cesspool of misery and hatred. A bigger pile of cynical ****s you will not find. And the Reid hire met with about a 90% approval rating. When 90% of this fetid hell-swamp loved the hire, if you're on the other 10% side you are, in fact, crazy. |
Hell, I was wrong - it was 95%
https://chiefsplanet.com/BB/showthread.php?t=268484 315 to nine. ****ing 9 people on this board disliked the hire. BWillie, unsurprisingly, was among them (Jesus Christ that guy is just ALWAYS wrong). Blackhelicoptors hated everything. Dirk, Munson and WhiteWhale (who my memory serves was primarly a DC poster) are the only 'credible' votes against Reid. There has never EVER been that sort of consensus form up around a decision this franchise has made. Even the Mahomes pick wasn't met with that kind of uniform excitement. No, if you disliked the hire, you're a dipshit of Kietzman, BWillie and Wallcrawler proportions. |
Quote:
As for BWillie, well, that just speaks for itself. LMAO |
Quote:
|
Quote:
But "Horrible Hire" is the standard Keitzman set here and thaVirus half-heartedly endorsed. No, even grading on a curve, nobody of sound mind thought this was a 'horrible hire'. Mediocre? Likely to eventually disappoint? Oh fine, that was a perhaps more commonly held position. But that's not what that ****ing raging dipshit Kevin Keitzman was saying. Lord almighty I hate that guy. |
Quote:
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
We have to remember Reid was coming off a very disappointing season with what the media deemed "The Dream Team" or some shit like that.
|
Quote:
|
Yeah but he didn't run the ball when I screamed at him through the TV set so he's still not a great coach but don't pigeonhole me into saying he sucks even though all I ever do is bitch and whine about him and come up with explanations for how anything he does right is due to the team he's surrounded by even though he's responsible for selecting, hiring, and coaching all of the people who prop him up
/Wallcrawler |
If you take into account that the Patriots playoff wins from 2001 to 2006 were tainted because of Spygate, Andy is well ahead of Belichick...
|
Quote:
Quote:
Just didn’t seem weird to me given how miserable CPers are and definitely were at that point in time. Mfs wanted a Super Bowl more than anything and most people didn’t think Reid would ever be able to deliver one so I wouldn’t be surprised if anyone didn’t like the move at the time. |
Quote:
|
Media actually though he was gonna pass Shula. He wasn't just a few games behind. Over 20 I think.
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
Andy is just as much responsible for Patrick's success as Patrick is for Andy's success. Patrick himself has said this. In fact, in interviews, it's the one thing he repeats almost every chance he gets across multiple years. What did Bill Walsh do without Montana? Belichick without Brady? Holmgren without Favre? The list goes on and on and on. And considering how some other coaches have absolutely WASTED HOF talent at QB, Andy gets a lot of bonus points for absolutely maximizing the Patrick Mahomes era. DON SHULA got Dan Marino one SB appearance and shit else apart from getting pounded in the postseason. The guy is on a short list of coaches who MIGHT be better than Andy and he didn't come close to what Andy is doing with one of the greatest QBs ever. The greatest five year run in NFL history and you're still whining. Put some bricks in your pockets and take a long walk off a short pier. |
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Carrying Donovan ****ing McNabb to a Superbowl wasn't impressive for the brain dead morons who didn't like the hire?
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
Quote:
All I’m saying is, dude was 10-9 in the postseason prior to coming to KC. 1-4 in NFC Championship games and 0-1 in the Super Bowl. He was basically Kyle Shanahan. It was a great hire for a floundering franchise as it helped stabilize things and make us respectable again, but I just don’t think it’s weird that some fans, who were starved for a Super Bowl, would question whether or not Reid was a great long term hire. |
Quote:
Quote:
Please, do remind me of all the championships Andy Reid was able to win before Patrick Mahomes. You'll have an easier time finding his playoff collapses, he owns 2 of the largest in playoff history at 28 and 18 points just with KC. Don't forget that amazing performance where this alleged legendary offensive coach couldn't muster up enough offense to beat a team unable to reach the endzone. Mahomes has played in 18 post season games and he's been neck deep in shit down 2 scores 11 times. He's 9-2 in those games. It's pretty safe to say that Andy would have 0 rings without Mahomes. All 3 times he's win superbowls pat has had to come back from down 10. That tends to happen when you form a habit of wasting first and second down. That Unicorn wearing number 15 has been able to consistently overcome mistakes and missed opportunities to pull out wins on a level that no other qb in history has come close to. In all 7 post season opportunities down one score under a minute with answer or go home stakes, Patrick is 7/7. Brady was 5/11 for comparison. Andy Reid pre Mahomes was the NFL equivalent to NBA coach George Karl. One of only 9 coaches to win a thousand games with no title. Never got his Michael Jordan to put him over the top. Does anyone here honestly believe that if Mahomes is kidnapped by aliens to play in the interstellar league the week before the playoffs start, that Big Red could do what Doug Pederson did and make a title run with his backup qb? No 15, no Superbowl win. It is what it is. Be offended if you like. |
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
How about Noll without Bradshaw? Walsh without Montana? Jimmy Johnson without Aikman? Bill without Brady? Shula without Griese? Seems to be a trend, which continues to show your unjustified hate for Andy and nothing more. |
1 Attachment(s)
The impact of Mahomes and Reid is INCREDIBLE - take a look at this chart
|
The 70's and 80's were dark days.
Marty gave us FALSE hope in the 90's We regressed in the 00's and early 10's until Reid came aboard. Then with Reid and Mahomes, holy shit we have the best win percentage in football during that time by a mile. This years record actually went slightly backwards! LOL |
Quote:
Metric 2017 Chiefs 2024 Chiefs Regular Season Playoffs Division Record AFCW Titles AFC Titles Super Bowls |
Quote:
Will the Chiefs win more Super Bowls after Reid retires than they won with him? We'll do it on a rate basis given that Mahomes will likely play more seasons with Reid than without him. And sure, he may play some of those years on the backside of his career, but he played the first few on the upswing of it as well. And the new coach will get credit for any development that Reid was responsible for. So if Reid is just some choking hack who's riding on Mahomes coattails, any sort of replacement level HC should be able to have a GREATER success rate than Reid has, no? So - go on record. What's our championship success rate going to be with a new coach once Andy retires? Better or worse? |
Quote:
|
Quote:
The guy is a worthless idiot. |
wallcrawler is a disease
the only coach to win 100+ with two franchises and mahomes gets all the credit LMAO |
HOLY SHIT did he really compare this guy to andy reid
https://www.basketball-reference.com...karlge01c.html mr one time NBA finals appearance is in league with the 2nd or 3rd greatest NFL coach ever? LMAO FIRED 5 TIMES |
Quote:
Andy needed his HOF QB to take the next step. |
Quote:
Actually, even better question. What is Belichicks WINNING PERCENTAGE without Tom Brady? |
i have to hear from countless fans on twitter how patrick is nothing without andy and then i come here and wallcrawler compares andy to an NBA marty clone
JFC |
Wallcrawler, what are Andy’s positive traits as a head coach? Since you don’t want him to leave, surely you recognize the things that make him an elite coach in this league other than, “He’s got Mahomes and is winning Super Bowls, so good enough”
|
The hole in the argument is Reid didn't chase a ring because Mahomes was here. Reid signed off on him when he had a veteran QB, had the balls to sit him for a year when a lot of coaches wouldn't do that, and worked to develop him into the guy he is now.
It wasn't like he was 6th round pick they got lucky on. Mahomes was a guy they spent years scouting and aggressively went after in the draft because they thought he was great. Which looks genius now because you can find plenty of mock drafts and information where people thought Mahomes was a late 1st or even 2nd round talent. So he wasn't a slam dunk #1 pick either. Heck yeah Mahomes is the difference but the reason he's in KC is because Veach and Reid identified and developed his talent better than the 31 other teams. |
Every top tier Hall of Fame HC has looked completely pedestrian without a top tier QB. And if they did win without that top tier QB, it was either a total fluke and they never made it back or they had an elite defense.
Most top tier HC's flat out miss the playoffs without a great QB (some miss the playoffs even WITH a great QB), and yet Andy almost consistently made the playoffs even with McNabb and Alex Smith. Andy maximized the amount of talent he had around him to great effect every single time. Without Mahomes, he got consistent playoff berths. With Mahomes, he has 3 SB's in 6 years. Andy is one of the greatest HC's of all time. Plain and simple. |
Quote:
Seriously. If you’re gonna make that comparison at least have the decency to call him Jerry Sloan |
Quote:
We've seen the same thing even with Mahomes. We've won critical games over the years with Matt Moore and Chad Henne when Mahomes was out. He can coach QBs. |
|
Quote:
Matt Moore going blow for blow with Aaron Rodgers and winning against the 6-2 Vikings. Chad Henne stepping in for the Browns and Jaguars games in the playoffs and playing well despite looking not great in Miami. Dude maximizes talent literally everywhere he goes. It's just facts. |
Quote:
People hated that Andy traded for Alex Smith People hated that they didn't draft Geno Smith People hated that they drafted Eric Fisher Andy's first few years looked exactly like the Marty Chiefs. Very good team that ends up ****ing itself spectacularly in the playoffs. Andy was 1-6 in the playoffs over a 9 season stretch from 2009-2017 with the lone playoff win being over Brian ****ing Hoyer. The frustration Andy faced was 100% justifiable at the time. Fortunately he found his HOF QB bc that's the difference. That's why Belichick, Tomlin, Shannahan, Dungy and McCarthy have any of their accolades bc without their QB's their reputation has been total shit. It's also why Marty never got where he wanted to go. Andy's legacy is now cemented. Previously he was a fringe first ballot HOF coach. Now he's a shoe in first ball HOF that will be on the Mount Rushmore of NFL coaches. |
Quote:
Chiefs AFC Championship game appearances: 1970-2017- one 2018-2023- six Chiefs Super Bowl appearances: 1970-2017- zero 2018-2023- four That’s all that needs to be said lol sums it up rather nicely |
It was never justifiable. Going 12-4 with Alex Smith is HOF coaching. Alex Smith was a loser.
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
PRE-MAHOMES REID. So yes. Karl appeared in the post season 22 times, finals once. Lost. Andy won a lot of games, appeared in the superbowl once. Lost. He's had some HILARIOUS Scorpion level faceplants in the post season before Mahomes. And don't think we forgot, you flip flopping cock smoker, you were just as critical of Andy's Gaffes as anyone here, going out of your way to mock him on your YouTube channel that has less subscribers than a channel committed to actually watching paint dry. https://youtu.be/HSpacfu5_Ck?si=glQ_q4JJRN21civE So sure, keep up the typical Clay shtick as the charge leading #1 super fan who never had anything critical to say about every time Andy Reid shit down his leg on a sideline. Hey dilphag9. It's just how your username reads. Perhaps if you had any semblance of reading comprehension, you may have chosen a better name. Why don't you run along and start a thread explaining to us all how Left Tackle isn't an important enough position to spend money on. It's just you know, the one that protects 15's blind side. Can't wait to read it. |
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
https://youtu.be/IwrYkvqXc9s?si=XWEDDdyQA1r9eZVU "I didn't understand the playcalling" "Hunt carried the ball 6 times in the first quarter, 5 times over the next 3." "Chiefs should have won this game by 30" "After the first 15 plays they forget what the hell they're doing." |
| All times are GMT -6. The time now is 08:53 PM. |
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.8
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.