Andy Reid's approval rating
 

A simple question. Do you approve of the job Andy Reid is doing as the head coach of the Chiefs?

Mahomes is the key to his success or failure now.

Yes

But no

Simple answer. **** and no

See playoff record for answer.

mr hunt needs to strip andy of all playcalling duties. demote him to manager. :D

The key question is whether Patrick will save Andy or Andy will ruin Patrick.

I have a fear of a cardigan-wearing, Proust-reading Mahomes looking over his reading glasses at us five years from now, saying, "I favor the safe, high percentage throws".

Horrible poll. Job approval? BS poll. You either get rid of him or keep him. I voted to keep him.

I'm not over the moon about Andy right now, but he is receiving far more blame than he should. Sutton should get at least half of the blame with his stupid schemes week in and week out.

And as mentioned in some other threads, how many times are we going to blame Andy Reid for the QB not being willing to throw the football where he should? That shows up all too often.

Reid should not and is not in any danger of being fired. We'll see in a couple years if that changes.

Remember the days of firing Haley and thinking Crennel would save us. LOL

If Sutton isn't replaced, its going to take at least an AFC championship appearance for me to not want Reid thrown out on his ass.

No

No Nagy with a bunch of vets gone...If he wants a 10 win season and a division title he better keep Smith and restructure that contract to make the pieces fit.

Otherwise it's 7-9 and a lot of pain.

No

No

Go **** yourself.

Reid got absolutely shredded by the media today.

He's the anti-clutch. The clock mismanager. Plays to lose.

No. Unless he figures out what a running back is.

Yes. Damn good coach. You aren't going to win playoff games with Alex Smith as your QB unless you play against Brian Hoyer.

There won't be a playoff for us unless you ride the hot hand with Smith and let him run the show with a full offensive roster. The loss of Conley was enormous

Is this satire?


LMAO

I’m never a fan of rehashing the trash.

I like young inventive and hungry for success coaches. Not fat ****s looking for a buffet to destroy.

Never a fan of the good ol boy coaches club = rehashing the trash.

Let's get Priest Holmes to coach this team

I'm not happy with the results and I'm not going to excuse any of the awful decisions he makes in big spots. But I also don't see any option out there that is clearly better. If you're going to replace him, you do it with someone better. Who is that?

You have got to be trolling.

Of course he is. He wrote that sentence as if he's a Chiefs fan.

Understanding the full play book and building that chemistry with the players all for what? So you can say goodbye to the #1 rated QB??

Madness.

At the end of the day he's a moron. Whatever he does well is erased by the things he does poorly.

He needs to go, he's too old and stubborn to change the things he needs to change to get him to a SB, and maybe win it. From his play calling, to not demanding more out for the defense, to being to silent about problems he then doesn't fix, he's toast.

The only thing saving him is Clark's ego that tells him him to go against the grain of common sense in hopes that he might someday look like he was the smart guy.

No.

You shit away two playoff games like he’s done in historic fashion, its inexcusable.

He works for Clark, Clark's a mother****ing football moron (even if he's a rich moron), so idiots like Andy are safe.

It all starts at the top..

Who is us? You aren't even a chiefs fan.

I wasn’t a fan of Andy in philly. Sure not a fan of him coaching my favorite team. Never have been. Most likely never will be.

A strong QB can cure a lot that hurts this team. Alex really was bad a more ways than one. Andy is ok. Mahomes won't fail to pull the trigger to get TDs and first downs.

But Andy got Alex the coveted 2017 QBR Trophy.

Not really fair to post a poll when everyone is still emotional after the loss.

It does bring out honesty..

Lol. With $17 mil we could go get 2-3 legitimate players to help Mahomes.

As for the original question, I feel the same way about Reid as I did about Marty...one of these days he will do something right in the playoffs. But I’m not sure I can wait that long.

No, it doesn't. People will feel differently in a week or two. Never make a decision when emotional. Cooler heads make better decisions.

Holy shit dude. Are you getting paid for all of your effort? I can't imagine anyone spending the kind of time you invest in alex Smith's defense without some kind of compensation.

This^


Basically it’s all about the stats.

The sooner we can get Mahomes as many reps as possible with Kelce, Hill, Hunt, and one more guy (plus help on defense) using Alex Smith’s money, the better. I don’t have any interest in wasting another year of those guys’ career on an average QB that is in his twilight years.

I’ll suffer 7-9 if it gets our QBOTF time with our best players.

He got us Hill, Kelce, and Hunt in the middle rounds. Also targeted and traded up for a very promising QB in round 1. He may have 3 assitants get HC jobs. He is a great HC.. just needs to not be an OC

No they won't. They will have been sold a line of BS, but deep down they know it's just Clark having his marketing staff spread pixie dust.

Sent from my SAMSUNG-SM-G920A using Tapatalk

I find more fear in a turtleneck-wearing, Flaubert reading Mahomes. Call me provincial.

He tried his best to put lipstick on a pig.

As long as he slaughters the pig now I'm good with him.

Still a 66 year old pig he's just biding his time with as well.

Bob's defenses have given up 22 points per playoff game since the Indy debacle.

He's had limited talent to work with.

I'm fine with him at DC.

Too bad you are too immature to know football. Maybe when you grow up little boy he's gone. Cleveland hopefully to get destroyed.

No fan thought that

I battled homers ALL OFFSEASON over the Romeo Crennel hire.

People thought he was talking us back to the playoffs. ROFLROFLROFL

It depends on what he does this offseason.

- If he keeps Sutton around, then **** him in his fat ****ing ass.
- If he keeps Smith around, then **** him in his fat ****ing ass.
- If he goes with some bullshit internal OC hire, I'm not as pissed but I'm still pretty furious.

If he gets rid of Sutton, sends Smith off to Siberia, and brings in some new blood at OC he will have entered into my good graces again. Of course, my opinion matters for shit outside of my own head, but that's what I personally want to see. I'm not watching a single game next year if Smith is on the team. I'll watch if Sutton is around, but I will be extremely disgruntled and will doubt his every move.

ROFL. Seriously?

Yes, delay the inevitable for one more season. The definition of insanity is what exactly?

So we go another year with no super bowl or playoff success, and we delay getting our young quarterback experience for another year. We enter 2019 with the knowledge that it will be a growing season for Mahomes, instead of getting that out of the way in 2018. In 2019 we basically have one year to make a decision on Mahomes before we have to decide on whether or not to extend to him the 5th year option. We miss out on potential draft pick(s) for Alex Smith, further delaying the rebuild/retooling of the roster.

Any other brilliant takes? What a wonderful ****ing idea, numb nuts.

What pisses me off the most is that Hunt allowed Reid to make the power play in hand picking Veach as the GM when Dorsey was shown the door. Hunt gave up the power that he sought to regain after the Pioli firing, as now there is no checks and balances for Reid. Veach could be a good talent evaluator, work magic with the cap and contracts but he will never have any control over Reid and coaching staff decisions. Veach and Donovan are extensions of Andy, and history is repeating itself again. 3 guys with different titles, but Andy holds and plays all the cards. Philly all over again. Watch him chase a ring by getting past their prime “name” free agents, maintaining a staff that will never challenge nor bring new innovation or energy to the team. His outward display of being loyal to assistants and never calling out players or officials is a front to hide his stubborn, tired, formula that affords him enough success to stay relevant but never revered.

Shit has to change. This franchise will tailspin if Reid is not given an ultimatum by Hunt (who allowed this to transpire) in that Reid must truly get out of his comfort zone. His 20 year formula has yet to work. He needs to think out of the box, humble himself, and be open to new contributions from young coaches and create accountability from both players and underperforming coaches.

If the Sutton/Smith/and promote from within for OC issues are not resolved soon, Hunt will see an empty stadium - with or without the shiny new qb.
Reid has to change now or be unemployd and regarded as one of the biggest chokers in NFL history as early as next year.

Unsure until I see what is done with Smith. If he’s on the roster opening day, I’m done. I would be fine with Sutton one more year as long as Mahomes is at the helm. Our D has played well enough. How many more points would we have needed to beat Indy, Pitt or Tennessee? Can Mahomes turn one or more of those 3 and outs/field goals into TDs? With better QB play, we don’t need an elite defense, we just need better Quarterbacking.

Said it before. If Smith is the starter next year I won't attend a single game until he is gone. If Mahomes starts and we see the same crap play calling and playing not to lose (and still losing) I'm done until Reid is gone.

I'll still watch on tv but will not buy a single damned thing.

Want 2 new coordinators with take no names and leave no points off the board no matter how much lead and time left on clock. Screw with being nice.

Tired of cast of coaches and quarterbacks. Lather, rinse and repeat. Just like CEOs, get fired at one job and get hired at another. Wish I was part of that country club. Was against it when it happened and have seen nothing that would change my mind. Too bad the Chiefs never had a QB when they tried the Pioli/Haley experiment. Who knows what might have happened if they had drafted one instead of getting Cassel.

Yes, Andy seems nice, give that man a big fat ring.

ROFL

I'm withholding my vote until Sutton's fate is determined

The answer to this question, it all depends on what your goals are for this team.

If you’re content with doing well in the regular season, while sh*tting the bag in the playoffs(this is Clark Hunts wet dream basically), then Andy is doing a great job and gets the approval.

If you’re not content with doing well in the regular season, while sh*tting the bag in the playoffs (as most fans are probably), then Andy can go **** himself and gets no approval.

I’m going with the second statement because I’ve seen this same old song with Marty and I’m sick of it.

Fat Andy had a 5 year plan to bring us a playoff win


He did that

Plus Andy Reid always says the same old things, “oh I gotta do a better job.” Said that in Philly and is doing that here in KC. Yet nothing ever changes, the common denominator stays the same blown leads and games. He only reinforces this franchises ability to choke. So not only no but **** no!

Yep.

Either Mahomes will make him look great, or foolish. I don't think much of Andy's tenure left in KC is up to him at this point. If Mahomes turns into Alex or better, then he's got some more time until the talent level drops or he just retires one day. But Mahomes comes off as the QB that will run the offense the way he wants to when he's comfortable with it. He'll follow Andy's commands at first, but once he starts to audible and lead, he'll take over to an extent and possibly ignore plays he doesn't think will work.

This is really our only hope.

****ing morons still think Veach is a fake GM

:facepalm:

please god no

A simple question asked 2-3 days after an ugly playoff loss. Kind of a predetermined outcome, yes????

Andy has choked in the playoffs 4 times in 5 years. The answer is gonna be no for me until he actually accomplishes something significant.

I choose Unsure until I know if Alex/Sutton will be here next season.

yup

Just when I think you couldn't be a bigger moron, you come up with another one :shake:

People just want one guy to point the finger at whether it's the offense or the defense.

It's stupid.

NO coach could make chicken salad out of the chicken shit that was on the field at the end of the game:

Frank Zombo, Allen Bailey, Daniel Sorensen, Darrelle Revis, Jarvis Jenkins and Bennie Logan all played at least 40 snaps in this game.

That's a fat lotta trash logging a lot of PT. And I'm not even counting Steven Nelson or DJ, who weren't exactly starting material this year.

It's a ****ing miracle that Bob Sutton rounded that group into near-elite form in the last four games of the season to get us INTO the playoffs. Because the D was NAILS down the stretch.

Ya'll need to get some perspective because Buddy Ryan, Bill Cowher and Tony Dungy could be coaching the defense and not get more out of that group.

I think he's an excellent HC.

I think he's a poor OC and bad at decision making in crunch time (be it the last two minutes or for playoff games.)

He's an excellent motivator (much like Marty) and an excellent evaluator of coaching talent (much like Marty) but completely unable to let go and allow those people to make the calls (much like Marty.)

There you go. Claynus says there's nothing wrong with Sutton. He's done as good as Buddy Ryan, Bill Cowher, Tony Dungy, etc. would do. The defense was nails. Nothing is wrong. Status quo on defense is great.

ROFL

Your trolling skills are good.

Look, he ain't perfect, but I'm telling you...when you're starting Frank Zombo and dudes you grabbed off the trash heap at ILB and CB...your options are limited.

And he coached that unit up enough to completely befuddle three potential playoff teams, which directly landed this team in the playoffs.

He's no Gunther...who was legitimately BAD when he didn't have top end talent.

When the defense was even just a tiny bit healthier the job he did against the Eagles was quite frankly, ****ing amazing.

He's a stupid scapegoat for a clear lack of talent.

John Dorsey sucked ass a GM getting defense talent on this team. We also have a shitty average QB who was risk averse. Bunch of scrubs on defense plus Alex Smith equals a lose. Some of you are too ****ing stupid to see that. A legit franchise QB marches the team down and wins that game, hell probably makes it a 34-22 type game.

Andy Reid has done a fine job getting a below average talent team where we are today. You aren't ****ing winning in January with Alex Smith.