Go On Record: Cam Newton, Geno Smith, or Matt Barkley?

[Bo's Pelini]

If Carolina decides to go a different route with the new GM and decides to trade Cam Newton would you give up the first round pick for him?


Or

Would you rather go with Geno Smith who's upside could be Aaron Rodgers or Matt Barkley who is polished ready to start day 1 with Matt Ryan potential?


Discuss.

[The Bad Guy]

I think out of all 3, Cam has the best chance to be great.

[The Bad Guy]

Cam truly has shit offensive talent around him. Steve Smith has aged, there's no #2, and Olson is nothing great at TE.

His attitude sucks, but in terms of skill, he's the best out of Smith and Barkley.

[thurman merman]

D) All of the above

[Bo's Pelini]

Originally Posted by BossChief

I haven't watched more than a couple quarters of Logan Thomas and I consistently see him mocked as a first round pick.

Why haven't there been more discussions about him on here?

All I know about him is what Ive read on Walters and other scouting sites and he seems like a promising high ceiling guy that should probably be talked about more.

Somebody should probably take up the cause for the kid on here because his upside seems higher than Barkley and maybe even Wilson.

I really like Logan Thomas but he's a project. I think he's struggled this year because the tools around him aren't that great and he needs to work on his mechanics.

Dude made a throw for a TD against GT that Cassel couldn't even dream of making.

[htismaqe]

Originally Posted by BossChief

I haven't watched more than a couple quarters of Logan Thomas and I consistently see him mocked as a first round pick.

Why haven't there been more discussions about him on here?

All I know about him is what Ive read on Walters and other scouting sites and he seems like a promising high ceiling guy that should probably be talked about more.

Somebody should probably take up the cause for the kid on here because his upside seems higher than Barkley and maybe even Wilson.

He's raw, isn't a terrific pocket passer, and plays for Frank Beamer.

On the flipside, he's a physical FREAK. 6'6" and pretty fast for 250+ pounds.

[htismaqe]

Originally Posted by Bo's Pelini

I really like Logan Thomas but he's a project. I think he's struggled this year because the tools around him aren't that great and he needs to work on his mechanics.

Dude made a throw for a TD against GT that Cassel couldn't even dream of making.

This.

[O.city]

Thinking about taking up the cause for bray

[Bo's Pelini]

[The Bad Guy]

Originally Posted by Bo's Pelini

I really like Logan Thomas but he's a project. I think he's struggled this year because the tools around him aren't that great and he needs to work on his mechanics.

Dude made a throw for a TD against GT that Cassel couldn't even dream of making.

To be fair, my 3 year old just threw his lego across the room and I don't think Cassel could make the same throw.

[The Bad Guy]

Originally Posted by O.city

Thinking about taking up the cause for bray

Not me. His college coach is starting to make comments about him. I think he has to stay in school.

[Mr_Tomahawk]

Tyler Wilson.

[O.city]

Originally Posted by The Bad Guy

Not me. His college coach is starting to make comments about him. I think he has to stay in school.

Probably so



But I think he might have the highest upside of any guy in this class. It's just that it might be unlikely he ever gets there

[hometeam]

Im already on record as a Geno fan.

If we cant get Geno we have to try SOMETHING.

[Bo's Pelini]

Originally Posted by The Bad Guy

To be fair, my 3 year old just threw his lego across the room and I don't think Cassel could make the same throw.

[htismaqe]

Originally Posted by Bo's Pelini

That first pass is a perfect example. He kind of flicks the ball, doesn't even really step into the throw - and it goes FORTY YARDS.

It just wasn't very accurate - he under-threw the WR. He throws that over the top and it's a TD.