Donovan McNabb's Last Year With Andy in Philly

[Bowser]

Here is a look at what McNabb accomplished in Philly his last year with Andy, 2009 -

Games - 14
Att. - 443
Cmp. - 267
% - 60.3
Att./G - 31.6
Yds. - 3,553
Yds./G - 253.8
TDs - 22
INT - 10
20+ - 55
40+ - 17
Sck. - 35
Rate - 92.9

Let's compare that to the best QB against the blitz in 2016....

Games - 15
Cmp. - 328
Att. - 489
% - 67.1
Att./G - 32.6
Yds - 3,502
Yds./G - 233.5
TDs - 15
INT - 8
20+ - 39
40+ - 8
Sck - 28
Rate - 91.2


Andy traded McNabb to the Redskins in 2010.

Originally Posted by Lao Tzu

"Those who have knowledge, don't predict. Those who predict, don't have knowledge. "

[chiefzilla1501]

Originally Posted by beach tribe

Nice thread. Very telling.

This is what I've been saying all along. The only reason Alex is his guy is because he doesn't have a better option.

As soon as he and Dorsey find one, him and his vagina are gone.

I don't get people who say Andy Reid is stuck in the WCO and that's why he loves Alex Smith. He also loved McNabb. McNabb was not accurate, threw the ball deep a ton, and didn't make quick reads. Andy Reid will customize the offense to the QB. He's not married to a pure WCO.

[TigeRRUppeRRcut]

Reid traded Mcnabb's ass because of how he didn't take advantage of all the targets on the field and the team had a first-round exit despite having Maclin, Westbrook, Avant, Celek, DeSean Jackson. 60% completion with all of those weapons? His running ability took a nosedive after 2006.

It was an easy decision for Reid, he had Vick waiting on the bench who was a legitimate dual-threat QB.

Unfortunately, 2010 they drew the would be Champs/GB packers in round 1 and loss by one score to what was arguably one of the hottest defenses at the time.

[TigeRRUppeRRcut]

The 17, 40+ yard plays has far more to do with DeSean Jackson's freak ability playing in his sophomore season, much less to do with Donovan.

[SAUTO]

Originally Posted by TigerUppercut

Reid traded Mcnabb's ass because of how he didn't take advantage of all the targets on the field and the team had a first-round exit despite having Maclin, Westbrook, Avant, Celek, DeSean Jackson. 60% completion with all of those weapons? His running ability took a nosedive after 2006. It was an easy decision for Reid, he had Vick waiting on the bench who was a legitimate dual-threat QB.

[TigeRRUppeRRcut]

Still don't understand how you are being nominated for a mod position. You are the definition of troll.

[SAUTO]

Originally Posted by TigerUppercut

Still don't understand how you are being nominated for a mod position. You are the definition of troll.

- no


Nice deflection though.


do you really want me to dispute your post point by point?

Let's start by talking about running hypocrite. Does that sound familiar?

[SAUTO]

Originally Posted by TigerUppercut

The 17, 40+ yard plays has far more to do with DeSean Jackson's freak ability playing in his sophomore season, much less to do with Donovan.

Here , what about this post?

Maybe hill would have done the same if Alex would throw him the ball when he was ruining wide open.

[SAUTO]

It's just easier to laugh at you at this point.

[TigeRRUppeRRcut]

Originally Posted by JASONSAUTO

Here , what about this post?

Maybe hill would have done the same if Alex would throw him the ball when he was ruining wide open.

English, learn it.

[Bugeater]

Originally Posted by TigerUppercut

Reid traded Mcnabb's ass because of how he didn't take advantage of all the targets on the field and the team had a first-round exit despite having Maclin, Westbrook, Avant, Celek, DeSean Jackson. 60% completion with all of those weapons? His running ability took a nosedive after 2006.

It was an easy decision for Reid, he had Vick waiting on the bench who was a legitimate dual-threat QB.

Unfortunately, 2010 they drew the would be Champs/GB packers in round 1 and loss by one score to what was arguably one of the hottest defenses at the time.

Uhhh sounds a lot like your boyfriend....

[Mr_Tomahawk]

He's a goner


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[Gonzo]

Originally Posted by notorious

Trade, cut, execute. I don't care.


Just get him away from the Chiefs as quickly as possible.

And replace him with who? Kolb?
Serious question here. I'm just as unimpressed with him. Just wanna know what we should do here.

[TigeRRUppeRRcut]

Kelce led the league as a tight end. Maclin's TD and yards went down 50%, he attributes to mental setbacks after being the best WR with fewest dropped passes in 2015.

So it's Smith's fault that his players were tied for 2nd worst in dropped passes?

Ok, guy. Ok.

[TigeRRUppeRRcut]

Originally Posted by Gonzo

And replace him with who? Kolb?
Serious question here. I'm just as unimpressed with him. Just wanna know what we should do here.

Draft another potential replacement with the 3rd round pick or later. If he's a bust, we pull the trigger on a 1st round pick in 2018. We'll have the cap space to do it then when we move on from DJ and Tamba's contracts.

[MahiMike]

But could he play dodge ball?