Quote:
Originally Posted by JD10367
Ranking Cousins, Dalton, Tyrod Taylor, and Ryan Tannehill above Alex Smith is just plain stupid. Smith will never be Brady or Rodgers but he's better than those guys.
|
Cousins is WAY better than Alex.
Dalton and Alex are about the same, but Dalton has had better seasons than Alex has ever had.
Tannehill same thing. About the same but I would lean Tannehill. In 3 of his first 5 seasons, he had more TDs than Alex's career high. Plus Tannehill is trending up, while Alex is tredning down.
Tyrod is the interesting one. He doesnt have the look of a real QB. Yet, production wise, he is absolutely in the same category as Alex, only Tyrod has wheels and adds a major element to the running game.
Its funny to me that none of these guys are better than Alex in your opinion, yet it is impossible to come up with a logical argument to prove that.