Quote:
Originally Posted by htismaqe
No, because Gosselin ONLY listens to his sources. He doesn't try to be scout, he's in the prediction business.
What gets guys like Kiper in trouble is that they try to pretend to be scouts and then when it gets close, they change it all up. Kiper wants people to believe he's a scout when in reality, he too is in the prediction business.
I think Scott Wright does a fairly good job of analyzing players, not just QBs. He's had Barkley and Smith 1/2 for most of the season.
|
The nice thing about Wright is he keeps his archives accessible, but he's as bad with QB's as anyone. His top two QBs each year with their overall ranking:
2007
Quinn #2 prospect (miss)
Russell #5 (miss)
2008
Ryan #6 (hit)
Brohm #28 (miss, shouldn't have been in top 100)
2009
Stafford #1 (I'll say hit, some will say no)
Sanchez #6 (miss)
2010
Clausen #10 (miss)
Bradford #11 (Incomplete maybe?)
2011
Gabbert #9 (miss)
Locker #26 (too early?)
Newton #29 (miss, too far back. Should be ahead of 1 and 2)
2012
He, like the rest of the world, liked Luck (1) and Griffin (5) but had Wilson at #152.