[Nightwish]

Originally Posted by Uncle_Ted

I agree as well. With the exception of a few episodes, the second half of the current season has been awful. It'll be interesting to see if the revelation of the new cylon(s) is "believable" within the context of the show. I already think that the whole "5 hidden cylons" story arc is pretty weak, though, so my expectations aren't too high.

I chuckle every time an ad for the show brings up "the best show on TV" quote ... I doubt the TV critic that said that would still say it today.

I was religiously hooked on BSG until they started in the whole Baltar trial arc. It's been serious suckage ever since! There are some arcs that have promise, if they would just flesh them out more - the Boomer/Hera arc was and could still be awesome, the hidden cylons arc has potential. They need to get off the Baltar trial arc as soon as possible, and they should never even have introduced the New Caprica arc. It just seemed like they tried it as an experiment, decided it wasn't going to work, then ended it in a very abrupt and choppy manner.