Quote:
Originally Posted by Red Brooklyn
Well, it isn't really a remake. It's the first time the musical has been adapted into a film.
But I don't understand your argument. It's a joke to be in the running because it's adapted and because there are big stars in it?
|
There are actors in there that were cast for star appeal versus "can they sing well." Russell Crowe is an obvious example.
And my point about it being a remake is that this is a movie that is based on a brilliant book. It has been adapted umpteen times and run on Broadway. If you're going to get nominated for it, it damn well better be ****ing brilliant. Other Oscar nominees and nominee wannabes are relying on highly original scripts.
So yes, it's a joke for this to be nominated. Best performances, yes.