The Rome for Italian
Quentins for sandwiches (get the potato or cheddar soup in a bread bowl)
CJ's for Chicken Wings - don't forget the loaded chips
Flatbranch for a pretty good variety of lots of stuff and a decent micro-brew.
The Gyro place is the International Cafe on 9th; very good Gyros.
And Wise Guys pizza in the back of McNally's bar for the best pizza and the only decent Chicago Style in town.
There are a few more, but that should get you started.
If you can't draw a crowd, draw dicks on the wall.