Quote:
Originally Posted by Direckshun
And Geno would not be 1st overall quality hardly any year.
|
I disagree. Pretty hard, actually. Not just pretty hard. I disagree vehemently.
I greatly prefer Geno to all of the first QBs taken between 2005-2011. Coming out of college, that is. The only guy I have to think twice about is Stafford.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Direckshun
But guys like Joeckel, Richardson, Werner, or Fisher legitimately could have been.
We need to break this down.... hold on. Let me return in 5 minutes, and lay my point out list-style.
|
I'll gladly break it down with you, but I'd rather have Kalil over the two tackles and Miller over Werner. I don't know enough about Sheldon Richardson to claim that he's better than Fletcher Cox, and probably not even JJ Watt. And Watt was a 4-3 DE at Wisconsin.
Again, we're talking positional value. Could Richardson be a JJ Watt? I wouldn't rule it out. What' the likelihood of reaching that ceiling? Not so great, especially considering his lazy reputation in college.