Originally Posted by O.city
Preface this by saying I'm high on Geno than you are. But with that, I don't think you are quit playing positional value into your rankings here.
And frankly, I'm tired of playing it the way we have. I'd rather take a chance on a QB who might have more risk attached than a DL who has less.
In my OP, I totally ignored positional value. So there's that.
I think people are getting too much of a confirmation bias with Geno. A bunch of folks watch his highlights but ignore the score of lowlights he has up. For every brilliant game, there's games where the offense collapses. For every great throw, there's a pass that falls five yards out of bounds.
I really like Geno and like everybody else, I'm starved for a QB and I want us to draft one.
But this fanbase is getting its hopes up waaaaay too high on this guy.