Everything I've seen out of Star seems to suggest that he's incapable of rushing the passer the way JJ Watt does it. I think we're better off drafting Damontre Moore and praying he can bulk up enough to play on the line than wasting a pick on Star "Dontari Jackson" Lotulelei.
I disagree with you 100% on the QBs, dude. Using your criteria for the #1 overall pick, "The #1 overall pick should be made for a player who will be an integral part of your Super Bowl run," that rules out EVERY PLAYER IN THIS DRAFT.
Basically, if you don't like any of the QBs this year, you're not going to get that special player. He doesn't exist in this draft. Your only option is to roll the dice on one of the QBs.
Star isn't it. None of the LTs are (because LTs don't win you shit) and none of these passrushers can do what we've seen out of a Von Miller.