Oh, my main league has 1 point for 15 yards receiving and 1 pt for 15 yards returning. So, in my scoring I would go Cribbs. Course we get .5 points per reception. That's a tough decision really. Cincinnatti looked really good on offense though, so I think Cribbs gets alot of kick-off tries which should boost his scoring. He could get 150 yards in kickoffs and I don't think DHB gets 90 yards in receptions. So, I guess Cribbs.
In your scoring, grabbing Thigpen was good, but I'm not sure I would trust him for a start yet. Oakland will score, for sure, but enough to really make the kick returner that relevant.. just not sure. I don't like to take chances on newcomers based on a single game. Cribbs is established as a great returner.