Quote:
Originally Posted by RunKC
Houston, Charles, Bailey, Poe, Tamba, DJ and Berry were the best core group of players left to Dorsey and all have either missed significant time or had bad health problems affecting their play.
3 winning seasons in a row. No Houston or Charles last year? 11 straight wins.
DJ is definitely right here..
|
And with DJ and Hali throughout his tenure, Pioli's teams did jack shit. With the additions of Houston, Poe, Berry and [chuckle]
Bailey, Pioli's teams still did jack shit.
It's just such a ridiculous argument. It requires that you simply have slept through the Pioli era, when
everyone recognized that the problem with this team wasn't it's stars. We were going out there with 8 Pro Bowlers and losing 10 games. Everyone knew it was a complete lack of roster depth and an inability to assemble a complete team that was killing the team.
It requires that you ignore the fact that Dorsey learned under Wolf, the same Ron Wolf who's always preached about horizontal roster building and creating depth and competition everywhere.
There's simply no question that this team and this roster has gotten better every single season under Dorsey. Immensely better, in fact.
Dorsey's a very good GM. Top 5? Eh, maybe, maybe not; there's a lot of luck there. But if you simply lump them as 'good', 'solid' and 'bad', there's no question that Dorsey's in the top 1/3 there; he's a good GM.