I'm in.
I nominate that all submissions be graded with from one to six
's, corresponding to Principles 1 through 4, and 6 and 7. Because Principle 5 (gruesomeness) is so subjective, submissions should also be evaluated with from 0 (none) to 4 (extreme)
's, to appeal to all sensibilities. Therefore, a typical grade may look like:
.
I further nominate that an attempt be made to separate the historical from the theological. Therefore, anything with supernatural evidence intrinsic to the event should be labelled with a
with no further evaluation. However, events traditionally associated with the supernatural are fine as long as it is judged without the supernatural element; therefore, the crucifixion of Jesus (assuming that the earthquake was natural) is fine, but the resurrection of the same gets summarily labelled with a
.
Do we start from now, or judge retroactively back to Post One?