Thread: Movies and TV Game of Thrones *Spoiler* Thread
View Single Post
Old 05-06-2014, 09:27 PM   #1984
Hawk Hawk is offline
MVP
 
Hawk's Avatar
 

Join Date: Jun 2005
Casino cash: $3454855
Quote:
Originally Posted by MagicHef View Post
What was Cersei's motivation for trying to kill Tyrion? Seems to me it was vengeance for the death of her son.

Obviously I have no proof because GRRM does not give numbers, but the way it's written leads me to believe that Catelyn has murdered more people than Cersei has.
Ha, sure, except Joffrey was still alive when she tried to have Tyrion killed in the battle of blackwater.

All of what you call "murders" by Catelyn could also be called punishment for crimes committed. You may not think they are justice, but there is certainly a valid argument that they are. None of Cersei's murder can be justified in that way, not even her first attempt at Tyrion.

Catelyn is no angel, but there is no doubt that based on what we know, Catelyn is not an evil heartless person in the way that Cersei is. You can keep saying it, but the evidence doesn't support it...yet.
Posts: 6,511
Hawk is obviously part of the inner Circle.Hawk is obviously part of the inner Circle.Hawk is obviously part of the inner Circle.Hawk is obviously part of the inner Circle.Hawk is obviously part of the inner Circle.Hawk is obviously part of the inner Circle.Hawk is obviously part of the inner Circle.Hawk is obviously part of the inner Circle.Hawk is obviously part of the inner Circle.Hawk is obviously part of the inner Circle.Hawk is obviously part of the inner Circle.