Quote:
Originally Posted by Saccopoo
I would. All day long.
Eli Manning, with the exception of what someone could consider an epiphany level moment in the playoffs in 2011, has consistently been a .500ish level performing QB that has been supported by a very good defense, wide receiver corps and running game. Prior to the 2007 SB, there were whispers of the concept of "bust."
Now that the Giants don't have that running game or defense, Manning is being exposed. Go look at what he is directly responsible for in terms of the Giants and their record this current football season. The guy is an absolute interception machine who is making horrible decisions with the ball.
Some people around here get completely enamored by what's on the back of the jersey and what the east coast media bias wants them to hear.
|
We've never seen this reincarnated form of Alex Smith play without a solid running game and elite defense. We have no idea what he would look like.
Probably wouldn't throw as many picks as Eli is, but INTs aren't everything.