Quote:
Originally Posted by O.city
Eli got incredible lucky to win 2 SBs, based on two flukey plays. He's absolutely not an elite qb, he's much too erratic
|
The flukey play to David Tyree was a superhuman effort to escape pressure (and even if he doesn't catch that, it still would have been 4th and 5). And it doesn't change the fact that he then marched the team into the end zone.
Not sure what other flukey play you're talking about. But 2 fluke plays shouldn't erase that 5 of the 6 games, Eli played terrific football. I'm bothered when people say any QB could win Super Bowls with their supporting cast. I don't think many of the elite QBs would have won a Super Bowl with that cast. It's because people find efficiency unimpressive. And that's a shame, because the efficiency model has been just as successful as the explosive offense model.