Hall of Fame?
 

Something different for a change. Do you think Eli Manning or Ben Rothlisberger will get into the Hall of Fame? Both won the superbowl twice and are starting quarterbacks for storied franchises for quite some time. I think there shouldn't but probably will. Hall of Famers should be difference makers and there are not. If Eli Manning ended up in San Diego or Ben Rothlisberger ended up in Cleveland neither of them would be in a discussion about it. Lets put it way if Eli Manning were the starting qb for the chiefs there wouldn't be a lock of the play offs or competing for the superbowl. If you would put Tom Brady or Peyton Manning in as chiefs qb there would.

I don't think they're first ballot HOFers, but they'll get in none-the-less.

ENGLISH MOTHER****ER, DO YOU SPEAK IT!?

Both get in.

cut off one of their legs and see how the do

Yep. It's a QB's game these days. If you win multiple SB's at the helm (and assuming you play an active role rather than being someone like Rex Grossman who mostly just benefitted from being on a great team), you're in.

I'm a long time NYG fan, watched Eli go from suck to troll. they both are pretty amazing athletes. I'll wait until they've ended their careers.

Both

Win multiple SB's, you are in. Actually rather simple.

Otis Taylor before either of these yahoos.

This

I picked neither and both.

Why?

Because of poll fail.

If Eli were qb for the chiefs I guarantee we would be in the playoffs