My top 3 would be

1. Geno Smith - I think he is the clear cut number 1
2. Matt Barkley - Decent different between him and Geno IMO, but slightly better than wilson
3. Tyler Wilson - Not too far behind Barkley.

Geno
Barkley/Wilson(Wilson has better arm, Barkley better decision making IMO.)
Bray (physical talent, good game last week)
Murray

My revised top five would be as follows:
1) Geno Smith
2) Tyler Wilson
3) Matt Barkley
4) AJ McCarron
5) Logan Thomas

At this point, I would put McCarron, Barkley and Wilson all in the same ballpark. Wilson has the most upside, Barkley the least. Wilson is the least polished, Barkley the most. McCarron has more upside, but is less polished than Barkley.

Tyler Wilson is overhyped. Bobby Petrino coached QB's often are overhyped. He has had a bad season without Petrino. You should move Wilson way down your board.

1. Geno
2. Wilson
3. Nassib
4. Barkley
5. Murray
6. McCarron
7. Bray

I just got a chance to watch some Zac Dysert (against Ohio State) and man - that kid has game. Updated List:

1. Geno Smith
2. Tyler Wilson
3. Zac Dysert
4. Ryan Nassib
5. AJ McCarron
6. Aaron Murray
7. Matt Barkley
8. Logan Thomas
9. Mike Glennon
10. EJ Manuel
11. Landry Jones
12. Tyler Bray

It strikes me that this class is unbelievably TALENTED and DEEP. You may not have a Luck or Elway type prospect, but you definitely have a ton of toolsy players.

Interested on why you have Bray below Thomas. That tat really bother you that much? ;)

Its the vandalism that bothers me. Poor judgement.

That is an issue for me as well. I wish I could interview him.

**** all the Glennon dumbasses who have him as a top 4 QB in this draft.

Ostrich neck won't even sniff the 3rd round.

Good to see someone here acknowledge Nassib.
You people who make top 10 lists and leave him out are crazy.
Like Sac said he hung with Barkley and last time they played he outplayed Smith.
My prediction Nassib will be the 2nd best qb from this class.
I have watched him up close for years and he is ready.
Runs NO style offense that his team changed to 2 weeks before opener.
Has a better arm right now than any Chief's qb and that includes Stanzi and trick shot boy.
Often times this year I have told my wife if Nassib were starting right now for the Chief's we would have a better record.
Don't be surprised if he out plays Smith in their bowl game.
SU defense may not be great but WV's is horrible.
That is why I like Smith #1. Even the playing field with Smith not having to make up for a horrific defense and he will dominate.

Wow. Just checked out the Nassib kid.

Pretty impressive release, and quick decision making skills. Ball arrives fast and on a line, too.

I can definitely see Drew Brees in him.

<iframe width="560" height="315" src="http://www.youtube.com/embed/JKJiruGcgFw" frameborder="0" allowfullscreen></iframe>

And now the Nassib bandwagoners begin. Just remember, I started this thing bitches!!!!

ROFL