Who should I keep?
 

12 team league
6 points for a TD
PPR

Starting lineup: QB, RB, RB, WR, WR, TE, FLEX

I've been leaning the entire offseason towards keeping Kaepernick for a 16th rounder but OTWP's thread about the lack of RB talent is making me question my decision. What do you think?

The round next to the players name is the pick I would lose for keeping them.

Damn....that's a nice problem to have. I would keep Martin for a 4th and hope to regret not keeping Charles.
Where will you pick, any idea yet?

Won't know where I'm picking until after the keepers are declared.

Ppr Charles he is supposed to be used in the receiving game a lot more.

My justification right now for keeping Kaep is this...

I can tie up my QB position with my last pick in the draft. That frees me up to draft RB/WR/TE with my first 8-9 picks. I technically wouldn't have to draft another QB until round 8 or 9.

I can see keeping Kaepernick, but he's the consensus #9 QB, you're probably going to have to grab another.
Assuming that a bevy of RBs will be kept, you don't pass on taking the guy with a ADP of 1.02 in the 4th.

You ain't gotta justify Jack....that's one think I love about fantasy football...unless you have a partner in one of the big money games, it's all my call.....

Here are my thoughts on who I think the other teams are probably keeping....

Ray Rice or Marshawn Lynch
Peyton Manning (more than likely)
RG3
Wes Welker (although with this team....who the **** knows)
Aaron Rodgers or Andrew Luck
Drew Brees
C.J. Spiller
Cam Newton
Arian Foster
Possibly Demaryius Thomas
Matt Stafford

Why no keeping AP?

The guy who has AP is probably going to be keeping Cam Newton because he's a Panthers fan and AP would cost him a 1st round pick....where Newton would cost him a 15th rounder. He could keep AP....but he's a moron and he'll put his feelings into the decision more than he should.

OK, I asked, so 'splain me one thing:

You're talking about keeping the consensus #9 QB in the 16th rather than the consensus #2 RB (and overall player) while he's keeping the consensus #3 QB in the 15th rather then the #1 overall player in the 1st.........now why is HE being a moron and you aren't?

Good question.

Because he's a Panthers fan. That's the ONLY reason that he's keeping Newton.

And I haven't seen any sites that list Martin as the #2 overall player.

The lowest I have seen Martin's ADP anywhere has been 1.4 and he is going 1.2 in many mocks.

This. Charles is awfully tempting though.

Very happy withi my keepers and wishing I could keep more this year. My biggest money ppr league and I am keeping Martin and Charles and releasing Julio Jones and Randall Cobb back into the draft pool.