Keeper Question
 

Ok, 12 team keeper league...

I need to choose between one of these options, the number represents the round where I lose a pick to retain him.

Aiyuk, 15
Amon-Ra St Brown, 12
DK Metcalf, 10
Diontane Johnson, 4

None of those guys is a WR1 this year, mix of low WR2 and WR3.

PPR league.

Thanks

Jesus what a choice lol. I'd be tempted on St. Brown or Aiyuk just for the value and i feel like they have about as much upside. DK is what my heart says but that qb room is scary.

St Brown's a no brainer imo.

St Brown is the no doubt pick there for me

Yeah, so tempted to keep him for the value alone in future years.

Feel the same about St. Brown though.

Aiyuk for me but St. Brown would be close 2nd. That's purely from a perspective that I think Aiyuk is more of a breakout waiting to happen and St. Brown could see fewer targets, especially as the season progresses if Williams comes back sooner than later.

I kept St. Brown... the value was too good to pass, especially if he becomes a consistent starting fantasy option.