Dorsey is a FAKE
 

Executive of the year? This is the same guy who had his choice of ANY player in college football and he drafted Eric Fisher. Your argument could be he traded for Alex Smith, but wasn't that Andy Reid's idea? Sean Smith, Marcus Cooper? Those pickups looked great for the first half of the year when we were playing quarterbacks like Jeff Tuel. Dunta Robinson looked like he had aids this year, another "big time FA signing." Travis Kelce, Nico Johnson, Sanders Commings, Eric Kush? I thought Dorsey was a gm who could find value at the top of the draft.

I have a bad feeling this year and next will resemble the 2010 and 2011 seasons. We do well and then the bottom drops out.

Really? 9 win turn around and this? Pass judgement after year three.

He drafted Jamaal Charles and Tamba Hali, and picked up Justin Houston in the third. You can't deny that type of record.

Huh?

I think the Chiefs have a very tall task in front of them this offseason, but that doesn't mean Dorsey's a "fake."

Jeff Tuel actually exploited the secondary a bit when he was told to get the ball out as quickly as possible.

You probably meant to say that those pickups were great when we were playing QBs like Blaine Gabbert, Tony Romo, Michael Vick, and Ryan Fitzpatrick.

Can't fix stupid.

I bet there are some internet sites that can back me up.

I like shock value. I'm a tool.

Dorsey didn't draft those guys.

RAGE

http://gifs.gifbin.com/062010/127737...orter-rage.gif

Berry was the obvious pick, and he kind of lucked out on Flowers dropping as far as he did.

Trolololololo

You should call your mechanic and schedule a tune up on your sarcasm meter.

Ok. I'm with ya. I thought I lost my mind for a minute.

There were a few times where Manning could have thrown deep and completed a few throws on the Seahawks last Sunday. Wanna know why that didn't happen? He got hit before he could make the throw.

We couldn't do that the 2nd half of the season..

Didn't Peterson draft those guys?

Letting Jared Allen walk and paying LJ may haunt him forever though.

Other than the near-meh alex smith move, pretty underwhelming beginning.

Pussy riot.

nah, adrian is a running back, braugh.......

Not one productive draft pick this year and the guy had the first pick.

This. He brought in some OK guys in FA but nothing special. The draft was a complete wash. Reid was responsible for the turnaround, not Dorsey.

Knile Davis wasn't a productive pick?

Was Luke Joeckel a better pick then Fisher? I don't think so.

You, sir, just earned a nomination for douche of the year.

Disagree on that one. Knile Davis proved as the year went on to be very much worth the value.

The rest honestly, is just fodder. Weak draft, with a front office group that really didn't know what they had here already, and took some developmental guys for the future. If you don't see more out of those guys this next season like Kelce, Eric Fisher, and Commings, then people might have a point.

But in Reality, when you are getting down to the 3-7th rounds of a draft, those are roster fillers on good teams.

And before someone goes, THEY WERE 2-14.

yes, They were 2-14, with a crap load of talent, that was held back by qbs that turned the ball over 37 times, and terrible coaching.

The Chiefs always were a talented team.

I would expect a much better influential draft this year.

You're a disgrace to the actual nWo.

I don't consider 242 rushing yards productive.

Great, so now we're comparing crap to crap.

We must judge this draft class strictly on 17 games. It's a must. What they do in year 2 is irrelevant when you want to be a gushing vagina.

WTF you doubt rainman

if he says so it is so

Well, when you have Jamaal Charles, you will have that.

He also showed well on special teams, and do you have any complaints about how he played in the playoff game?

Yes, because we can just look at a stat sheet and say Knile Davis was a wasted pick.

GTFO.

A backup rookie rb that didn't see the ball but maybe once or twice a game? I think he was a steal.

Who would you have picked?

How many trimesters would it be if you were to abort yourself now?

Hahaha.

:spock:

It's sad when the only positive draft pick we can think of is a backup RB who averaged 3.5 ypc and had 242 yards on the ground this year.

Dorsey comes from the Ted Thompson tree. His game isn't about blue chip free agents so I think he was a little off his game. I still think his buying spree had a lot to do with Clark Hunt giving an ultimatum that the team win now.

He was excellent (and this is the part I care about a lot more) at the scrappy picks. I think Kush has potential to start. I think Cooper has tremendous room to grow. I think Nico Johnson and Sanders Commings are going to be decent picks, and we'll see on Kelce (way too soon to say what we have there). Sherman is a borderline all-pro fullback. We don't know what we have in Catapano, but I like that pick too.

In terms of depth, Knile Davis and Abdullah were decent pickups. Same with Demps and Jordan. And I'd say Rishaw Johnson and Rokevius Watkins played pretty solid against San Diego for a bunch of scrub backups, wouldn't you? I'd say that Ron Parker and Jaye Howard looked just fine in that game too, wouldn't you? Even Zombo isn't a bad player considering where we got him from.

I don't think he deserves executive of the year because his big pick-ups were pretty so-so, but to rip on a guy who pretty much built a backup team that could beat the Chargers... Pretty good.

Its only sad if you don't remember that the team was already loaded with talent. It also had a +9 record over the season before, didn't have a second rounder, because that was your qb, and the only other guy than Fisher, who really would of contributed much anyway, was Kelce, and he was hurt. Not exactly on Dorsey that Kelce got hurt.

Want to blame him for Eric Fisher? Sure, fine, I think all of Chiefs planet, and Chiefs fans would go with that.

But, I reality, the second round pick, was Alex Smith, and he played really well.

So Fisher-Meh
Alex Smith- far out performed a second round pick
Knile Davis- Showed great burst, and a knack for special teams
Travis Kelce- Injured.

Kush-drafted as depth
Sanders Commings- hurt

I mean, its not outstanding, but really, its nit picking to call out a front office with their first draft class.

It's really sad that we already had the best rb in the NFL and that's why Davis saw limited playing time. What else are you sad about?

The FA we signed in the offseason

What free agents did we sign that are going to destroy our cap or are locked in for 5 years? The only one really is Bowe.

You guys ever try posting after giving yourself a stranger?

You ever given a stranger a stranger?

Once, but it was more frostbite than anything. Hard to stay warm under those bridges.

No freaking joke.

Kelce and Commings didn't even get a chance this year. And we know from Dorsey's interview that Fisher is going to be putting on 15 lbs and hitting the weight room.

These are the same clowns who said Poe was a terrible draft pick this time last season.

Dorsey Mantooth is a saint!!

Dorsey had the best year for any GM not to win a playoff game. Supposedly.

I'm pretty blown away the Smith trade is being put in thw in column.

I'm sorry, but I just don't see Kelce doing shit in the league. IF he comes back 100% healthy and IF he is making the most of his offseason time to improve, there's still the issue of staying healthy and taking control as the legitimate starting TE that the team has been lacking.

I'll be delighted if we draft Ebron or Amaro. If Kelce wants to join the party as a great player, then we just acquired a ****ing lethal double TE set. If he's shit and cum like he appears to be, then we at least still fixed the TE spot.

I'll never forgive him for drafting Blackledge

Lmao

this thread makes me

http://static.guim.co.uk/sys-images/...ry-man-001.jpg

:hmmm:

Now you're just being racist.

Actually I agree. He didn't really do anything. Reid wanted Smith. Marcus Cooper fell into his lap, complete luckballed on that one. Time will tell, but his draft didn't look amazing. Honestly, lots of guys Pioli drafted were the ones who performed for us.

Schwartz, Sherman, Devito, and Abdullah were all vital parts to our success this year.

How exactly did Marcus Cooper fall into his lap?

Trollollol?

I don't see how anyone can say he won't do shit in this league.

What's he done so far?

SNR? Been a long time contributer to his board, provided takes agreeable and disagree-able to many on many topics, provided humor (once or twice) and spirited debate (maybe once). So the real question is, "what have you done, NWO "

Still to early to tell on Dorsey.

A lot of people around here are going to be surprised when the #1 overall pick turns out to be a good LT, which is odd.

Once you go Blackledge

You never go back from the ledge

JFC Its 1 ****ing year. Change your tampon.

LMAO

If he turns out to be good, I'll admit I'm wrong.

But at this point, what do you REALLY have to base that on other than hope?

The guy didn't play well and couldn't stay on the field to boot. Horrible pick.

This for the most part.

Andy Reid deserved COY far more than Dorsey deserved an award.

Dorsey > King Carl > Scooter

Suck it.

It really goes without saying but...

Better than "Bad" does not equal "Good".

We really have no idea what Dorsey is at this point.

True. It's year 1. To anoint him or damn him at this point is foolish.

I don't like the job hes done at Greenbay. They look even less talented than us (outside of Rodgers).

How much of that is he even responsible for?

I don't really know what he did with the Packers.

Their o line stinks, other than that they have talent all over the place.

@ OP, have a dose of AIDS with an Ebola twist on the house

Doesn't really give you a warm fuzzy considering that their very first pick was o-line.