Would the following situation make you NOT freak out about not drafting Geno Smith?
Ok, let's imagine our coaches simply don't like Geno Smith and don't plan on drafting him... would you be ok with the following ....
Trade Round 4 pick for Alex Smith. Trade #1 overall pick down to the 8-12 range in exchange for a 2013 Rnd 2 and 2014 Rnd 1 Take Dee Milliner or Kenny Vaccaro with that pick. Take Tyler Wilson or Matt Barkley (or insert any QB other than Geno here) with our #2 pick. Personally I would be ecstatic if we swung a deal like this. So, I ask, would this be a situation that you wouldn't freak out about? |
Only Matt Barkley. Tyler Wilson is a ****ing turd. I'm tired of giving that asshole excuses.
Ask me if there's a remote chance that Barkley is available at 2, though. |
It just needs to be one of the top 3 QBs for me. How it gets done is not overly important.
|
:hmmm:
Trade down, start Stanzi and then draft first again next year. |
We are not trading down. Nobody wants our pick.
|
Quote:
|
I mean who wouldn't want Jonathan Ogden on their team? Of course somebody will trade up for him.
|
Quote:
At least we'd be able to one-up Jags troll and steal Bridgewater from under his nose. |
I do not want Alex Smith on this team he represents every retread QB fail we ever had.
I want us to draft a QBotf with our first pick however if we can buy a year to draft the #1 QB in next years draft I'd be ok with that but that is unrealistic to actually happen so I only want to draft Geno Smith with our first to be happy. |
Quote:
I do however think that Milliner and Vaccaro will be great picks in the 8-12 range. |
I would be cool with that scenario. Unfortunately that won't happen.
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
It's beyond stupid to judge a guy like Smith before he even has a chance to play a down here. And to be honest, Smith for a 4th rounder is a damn good deal if it plays out that way. |
Quote:
Most fans count playoff wins and Lombardi trophies. We define "success" like the Browns and Lions. |
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
we trade our #1 overall for a pick in the 8-12 range and a Rnd 2 AND a 2014 Rnd 1 We then trade that 2014 Rnd 1 pick to swap our top Rnd 2 pick with a Rnd 1 20-25 pick! BAM! Ok, now that may be just a bit ridiculous. :D BTW I do agree with you, should be some serious mid to late Rnd 1 value |
Quote:
Since when did CP become the stupid Chiefs BBS? Didn't we used to be the smart one? |
Quote:
The point was to show how ridiculously stupid it is to say that Alex Smith (if he even comes here) is a failure and "more of the same" before he plays a down. Especially if we still take a QB early in the draft. |
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
If you take 4 rocks and throw them at a window, breaking the glass, is it reasonable to assume that the window will suddenly withstand the 5th rock and remain unbroken? We've seen this before. Several times even. Alex Smith doesn't deserve the benefit of the doubt. |
I'm going to say no because waiting for Alex Smith's contract to be up will make all of the exceptional talent on the team that much older and worse for the wear. So Gaz option for me.
|
Quote:
Stupid Blackledge curse just wont let us take another QBotf in the first round. Hope we break the curse with Geno Smith. |
Yes, that would be great.
|
There's no lipstick fit for this turd of a situation.
|
The only thing I would change is going BPA in every round.
|
Id still be pissed passing over geno, but i woulnt freak out if we could get milliner and Barkley, but it isn't going to happen.
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
Alex Smith is game manager not game winner. |
Quote:
I don't care who the **** he is. The team he's on doesn't want him. We shouldn't want him either. He doesn't deserve the benefit of the doubt, or anything else for that matter. **** Alex Smith. |
Quote:
I don't believe anybody wants it |
Quote:
One man's garbage is another's garbage. |
Quote:
|
I said no. I'm tired out trying to be too cute and maximize "value". **** that, give me the best QB in the draft and if that fails, rinse and repeat.
|
Quote:
we would hear that twice a year for ever |
Quote:
|
To be clear, NO ONE is claiming Alex Smith is a franchise QB. But to write him off as garbage is just stupid. Those with this OPINION may end up being right... but acting as if they KNOW at this point is a Charger's fan level of dumb.
I can't believe I am here defending Alex Smith... BUT the amount of pure knee jerk stupid that is running rampant today has forced me to try to be the voice of reason here. To not like Alex Smith is fine, normal even... but to go batshit crazy because we MAY have traded a FOURTH round pick for him is ridiculous. |
Quote:
But I don't have any reason to believe he's going to succeed either. His history, and the Chiefs history, suggest it will be another failure in a long, long line of failures. |
Quote:
Damn, frustration has apparently turned ChiefsPlanet into a haven for idiocy like the other Chiefs boards. |
Quote:
Matt Cassel was pretty decent with Charlie Weis around. Alex Smith was pretty damned good with Harbaugh around. What's going to happen next? |
Quote:
|
Quote:
Someone someday needs to teach the definition of insanity to Clark. |
as long as they address their QB position before pick 35 I like to give the new regime the benefit of the doubt
if we go with Alex Smith and don't address the QB situation before/on our 2nd round pick I will be pretty disappointed |
Quote:
|
Quote:
It's what we've come to expect as Chiefs fans. |
Quote:
EDIT: And no, I don't have any more good will to give them any more chances. I've suffer through watching this team for too long, waited for them to get the #1 pick for too long. I am ****ing fed up with it. They either do what all the other successful teams do or I am getting off the train. I am not rooting for a team that has no interest in winning. |
Quote:
|
Id want more for our #1
|
Quote:
Einstein's Definition Albert Einstein once said "The definition of insanity is doing the same thing over and over again and expecting different results". Article Source: http://EzineArticles.com/12047 |
If we trade for Smith and pick Joeckel with the #1 and get EJ Manuel with our #34...but after today I'm not sure he will fall to the second round
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Yes! Thanks for explaining it much better than I've been doing. 2 choices here are:
1) Draft Geno. FTW! 2) Get Alex Smith, top CB And Barkley/Glennon |
It's sad that after trading back, taking a corner to replace the talented young one Pioli let walk for nothing might be the right move, but it might be the right move.
|
Quote:
They won't be there in the 2nd round. |
Quote:
|
Two things:
Alex Smith would be a terrible trade under any circumstances. If no QB is worth the #1 pick, nobody is going to trade up to acquire the #1 pick. None of the other players at the top of this draft are far enough separated from the 2nd tier players at their position to warrant a cost of multiple picks. And probably one more thing: There won't be a QB worth a damn sitting there at 34. |
Quote:
|
Quote:
1)Saying that NOW about Smith is reeruned. Maybe end up true but come on. 2)Yep, I doubt we will find a trading partner, the top of this draft RIGHT now doesn't look great. 3)Saying that there DEFINITELY won't be a QB at 34 is more reeruned than your first statement. I'm not against Geno in any way, but I'm also not ready to go overboard reactionary about it. |
Quote:
2). Yep. 3). There will be QBs there. They won't be good enough to unseat Alex Smith though.. Here's to 5 more years of mediocrity. |
Quote:
(none of this has anything to do with Geno Smith. this is all about Alex Smith) Quote:
Wilson might be a possibility, but let's be realistic about him: if he's in freefall let him stay in freefall. That one reads like a bad gamble. Which is a shame, because I had hoped there was something there. (I don't think he falls though. I think somebody takes him in the 20s.). |
Quote:
|
Quote:
I get that Reid and Dorsey aren't blind, and that would be my hope if this scenario plays out, but this fan base and media group are full of idiots. Decent play from Smith may buy him time. That's why I prefer taking a chance elsewhere. I just fear the decent QB much more so than a risky boom or bust one. |
All times are GMT -6. The time now is 03:03 PM. |
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.8
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.