Year before with Smith? No super bowl

Smith gets replaced? Super bowl.
Posted via Mobile Device

This post drips with irony.

The fact of the matter is that people denigrating Smith as worse than Cassel are an incredibly small minority. I don't know if there are more than five posters who post regularly who have made such claims.

You're doing the exact thing you're accusing others of doing. There are literally hundreds, if not thousands, of reasonable, articulate posts that have explained why Smith won't work and they are the exact tenor of the first example you list.

Instead, you'd rather continue on with a constructed narrative that ChiefsPlanet is Fox News. It is, if you have a confirmation bias.

LMAO

Yeah, I suppose going to OT against the Super Bowl winning Giants in 2012 made Smith a failure.

LMAO

Hate on, Haters.

Yeah when I was younger, it didn't matter. I just loved watching the games. Of course...we were in the playoffs or in the hunt every season.

He absolutely failed in that game. At a Casselian level.

It was a putrid performance.

facebook would be a great place for you to collectively suck off the chiefs.

Meanwhile, a lot of us are done giving the benefit of the doubt due to shitty regimes since 1969.

can you take wendler with you. thx now here a nice video
<iframe width="420" height="315" src="http://www.youtube.com/embed/wlq0lYB3iSM" frameborder="0" allowfullscreen></iframe>

I didn't say it was a failure.

All I did was disagree somewhat with your post saying it was complete speculation
Posted via Mobile Device

i love the fact that people keep throwing this game manager title on cassel.

He wasnt a game manager. He was a game loser.

Alex Smith manages the game so that his team doesnt turn the ball over, and wins.

Cassel is garbage. Alex Smith is more like recyclables. He can be reused, and be useful. Garbage just pollutes the air.

Oh, the chiefs will be fun this year... to laugh my ass of at.

Honestly, before CP I enjoyed the Chiefs alot more. Now I over analyze things. So I'm going back to that, while still posting on CP.

In 2008 and 2010 he was a game manager who won plenty of games.

Just like Alex Smith.

Cassel has had more success in the NFL than Alex Smith, unfortunately for you.

Two winning seasons > 1.5 winning seasons.

Riight.

The 49ers weren't leading 14-10 before that vaunted 49er's defense gave up a 4th quarter touchdown, right? Alex Smith didn't lead them to a tie, right?

Williams' muffed punts hurt the 49ers and put them in bad positions but it's Smith's fault they lost.

Highest, qb rating of anyone vs the giants in that playoffs.

Higher than Matt Ryan, Higher than Aaron Rodgers, higher than Tom Brady.

Didnt turn the ball over, didnt have ted ginn, or josh morgan. Had Brett Swain, a fat michael crabtree, vernon who he found for two tds, including the go ahead in the 3rd quarter. Had the team in position to go to the super bowl despite the fact that two of his top three receivers were PRACTICE SQUAD GUYS.

Game was played in a monsoon, against a defense in the giants that chewed up everybody in the playoffs, including the league MVP in aaron rodgers.

So **** off with that he got destroyed bullshit. Bottom line is, without kyle williams effing up twice, they are in the super bowl.

Btw. Didnt Colin Kaepernick just lose the super bowl with a MORE talented team than alex smith had?

Smith going 0fer on 3rd downs in that game is what cost them.